Nov 18, 2026 6:10 AM

Neither Tommy Carr nor Bryce Underwood provided anything resembling competent quarterback play against Oregon, raising even more questions about Michigan's offensive staff, quarterback development and the direction of the program under Kyle Whittingham.

Remember when Michigan supposedly had two talented young quarterbacks capable of leading the program into the future?

Right now, the Wolverines don't appear to have one capable of leading a functional college football offense. It might not be entirely their fault, but they were the ones attempting to make plays on Saturday in Eugene.

Michigan's embarrassing 31-7 loss to Oregon on Saturday featured another miserable performance at the quarterback position, with both Tommy Carr and Bryce Underwood seeing action and neither providing much reason for optimism.

Carr completed four of his 12 pass attempts for 45 yards, finishing with a dreadful 14.7 QBR. Underwood wasn't much better, completing two of his eight attempts for 26 yards.

Related stories

Combined, Michigan's quarterbacks went 6-for-20 for 71 yards, averaging just 3.6 yards per attempt.

Read those numbers again.

Michigan completed six passes in an entire football game.

Meanwhile, Oregon quarterback Dylan Raiola, who began the year as a backup to Dante Moore, completed 20 of his 28 attempts for 341 yards and four touchdowns, providing a painful illustration of what a functional passing offense actually looks like.

Perhaps the most frustrating aspect of Saturday's performance was that Michigan finally established something resembling a productive rushing attack.

The Wolverines finished with 215 rushing yards, averaging 5.4 yards per carry. Freshman running back Savion Hiter led the way with 107 yards and a touchdown, while Carr contributed 43 yards on nine attempts.

Even removing Hiter's 70-yard touchdown run, Michigan averaged 3.7 yards per carry.

Yet the Wolverines couldn't generate anything through the air.

Andrew Marsh caught four passes for 46 yards. Only two other Michigan players recorded receptions. The longest completion of the afternoon went for just 18 yards.

That's absolutely pathetic.

The offensive line remains problematic, but at some point, the quarterbacks themselves have to shoulder some responsibility. Carr and Underwood are both talented players, but neither has demonstrated the consistency, accuracy or decision-making necessary to lead this offense effectively.

More concerning, neither appears to be developing.

Jason Beck was fired following the Michigan State debacle, and interim offensive coordinator Jim Harding's first game produced more of the same. Changing play-callers was never going to magically fix everything, but the continued regression reflects poorly on the entire coaching staff.

That includes Whittingham.

Michigan is now 5-5, has scored just 13 combined points over its last two games and desperately needs another victory to become bowl eligible.

The Wolverines have spent virtually the entire season searching for answers on offense and at quarterback.

Instead, they've managed to turn two promising young players into ineffective quarterbacks operating a completely dysfunctional offense.

That's not just a quarterback problem, that's a coaching failure.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy