Notre Dame Fighting Irish vs SMU Mustangs: Recruiting Comparison
Nov 17, 2026 1:00 PM

While elite stars dominate the headlines, unranked gems define this historic matchup. Discover how developmental standouts and recruiting mismatches could decide the battle in the trenches.

Notre Dame and SMU have rarely met on the football field throughout their history. They've played a grand total of 13 times with their most recent meeting coming in 1989 in South Bend. The Irish went on to a 59-6 victory and that's the last time the Irish and the Mustangs met on the gridiron. Eight of their total meetings came between 1949 and 1958 and the Irish hold a 10-3 all-time lead against the Mustangs. As infrequent as these teams have met on the football field, they've met even less on the recruiting trail. 

If you're just looking at recruiting rankings, there's very little comparison when looking at SMU and Notre Dame. But the rankings also tell a much deeper story. The level of underrated players that have emerged from both of these schools back the notion that high school recruiting rankings mean very little when they get to the collegiate level and, to varying degrees, both of these schools embody that mentality.  

Let's look at how these two teams stack up in recruiting rankings using the Rivals/On3 composite rankings to compare. 

NOTRE DAME OFFENSE VS SMU DEFENSE

The first thing I notice when looking at these rankings is the amount of underrated players make up the SMU defensive roster. Linebackers Brandon Booker (No. 908) and Alexander Kilgore (No. 524) are two of the three leading tacklers on the team but were unranked coming out of high school. Defensive end Marques White currently leads the team in sacks, tackles for loss and total pressures but was unranked coming out of high school. 

Related stories

The same could be said on Notre Dame's side of the conversation. Their leading receiver, Jordan Faison was an unranked player coming out of high school and was predominantly a lacrosse recruit, but he's worked his way into the spotlight at receiver. Quarterback CJ Carr (No. 68) was ranked as a four-star recruit coming out of high school and it's safe to say his performance the last two seasons has not been that of a four-star player. 

From a matchup perspective, the most intriguing is the Notre Dame wideouts against the SMU cornerbacks. Both Marcellus Barnes (No. 305) and Jayvon Thomas (No. 136) were four-star players coming out of high school as were wide receiver Jaden Greathouse (No. 158) and Micah Gilbert (No. 230). The biggest mismatch, in Notre Dame's favor, is Greathouse against nickel corner Jarvis Lee (No. 1150) who is the third lowest ranked player on SMU's defense. 

NOTRE DAME DEFENSE VS SMU OFFENSE

This side of the ball, more so than the defensive side, is where the 'underrated' aspect of SMU's team truly lies from a recruiting rankings perspective. The Mustangs only have four former four-star recruits in their starting lineup and three of them live on the offensive line in left tackle Drew Evers (No. 214), right guard Addison Nichols (No. 166) and PJ Williams (No. 64). Williams was injured in the first half of the Wake Forest game. If he's unable to go against the Irish, four-star recruit Andrew Chamblee (No. 336) will likely step in. 

It's the Mustangs skilled players against the Notre Dame defensive backs that will be really entertaining to watch. Receivers Yamir Knight (No. 2300) and Yannick Smith (No. 566) were both three-star players coming out of high school but Knight leads the team in receiving. Knight's matchup with four-star nickel cornerback Christian Gray (No. 112) looks lopsided on paper from a recruiting rankings perspective, but will be a premier matchup Saturday night. 

Tight ends Theo Melin Ohrstrom (No. 296) and Randy Pittman (No. 693) will be matched up with Notre Dame's safeties Adon Shuler (No. 295), Luke Talich (unranked), Joey O'Brien (No. 35) and potential Brauntae Johnson (No. 220). Notre Dame has had issues in the past covering tight ends. It's a matchup they should win based on the recruiting rankings, but like we've established, that doesn't mean a hill of beans when you strap on the pads at the collegiate level. 

CLASS RANKINGS

Here are the class rankings of the two programs from the last five seasons (247 Composite Rankings) 

NOTRE DAME

2026 - 5
2025 - 12 
2024 - 9
2023 - 12
2022 - 7

SMU

2026 - 35
2025 - 32
2024 - 117
2023 - 72
2022 - 80

Advantage: Notre Dame

------ 

Become a premium Irish Breakdown member, which grants you access to all of our premium content and our premium message board! Click on the link below for more.

Be sure to stay locked into Irish Breakdown all the time!

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy