SMU's Worst Loss of the Season Reveals a Familiar Problem
Nov 16, 2026 12:00 PM

The Mustangs built a season around second-half comebacks, but Wake Forest exposed the danger of repeatedly giving opponents an early advantage.

There is a version of this SMU team that showcases resilience.

The Mustangs fell behind Missouri State 10-0 after one quarter, with two turnovers and two missed field goals already on the ledger. They then grabbed the lead with four seconds left before halftime and won by 10. They trailed Cal 20-17 at the break before scoring 42 unanswered points. Boston College led 10-6 early before SMU's defense shut out the Eagles for two full quarters.

Six times this fall, SMU has reached halftime either trailing or holding a narrow lead. Four times, the Mustangs won anyway. The formula became something close to a personality trait.

Related stories

Then Wake Forest came to Ford Stadium on the saturday and the scoreboard read 42-0 at halftime.

There was no third-quarter surge available Saturday and no adjustment that mattered because the game had been decided in the first 25 minutes. The 49-7 final marked one of the worst losses of the Rhett Lashlee era and clarified something that had been sitting in plain sight for two months.

A team that spots an opponent's double-digit lead is betting that opponent won't be good enough to finish the job. Louisville was good enough. Syracuse was good enough. Wake Forest was more than good enough.

The pattern reads like a slow leak. At Louisville in September, SMU scored on its opening drive before giving up 14 straight points in the first quarter, including a touchdown pass after a short field. The Mustangs actually led at halftime and still lost by 10. On Halloween at Syracuse, SMU led 10-7 after one quarter before going scoreless in the second as the Orange scored 13 unanswered points. The comeback that followed ended with a blown fourth-quarter lead.

Both games had the same shape. The rally was real, but it arrived too late to make up for what came before it.

Saturday followed that pattern without the rally. Three first-half turnovers, a failed fourth-down attempt and only 40 passing yards deep into the second quarter left SMU buried before it found the end zone in the third.

The fourth-down decisions deserve their own look.

Lashlee has gone for it aggressively in the first half all season, and that approach has produced points in big games. It has also handed opponents short fields at moments when his offense clearly was not ready. Against Wake Forest, SMU went for it on fourth-and-1 at its own 26 in the first quarter, got stopped for no gain and watched the Demon Deacons reach the end zone five plays later.

None of this ends the year. SMU is 7-3 with trips to Notre Dame and Stanford remaining. With the ACC race and playoff talk both settled, finishing strong is what remains.

Notre Dame Stadium at night is not the venue for another slow start. The Irish will take a two-score lead and turn it into a long evening if SMU lets them. The Mustangs have spent all season proving they struggle to handle those situations.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy