Texas A&M Loses Five-Star OL To Notre Dame

Texas A&M football took a recruiting punch Friday, even as the Aggies continue to sit on top of the 2027 recruiting mountain.

Five-star interior offensive lineman Albert Simien committed to Notre Dame, giving the Fighting Irish a massive win over Texas A&M, LSU and Nebraska.

MORE: Texas A&M’s CFP Hopes Hinge On Portal Tackles

For Mike Elko and the Aggies, this one stings. Not because the class is suddenly in trouble - it’s not - but because Simien was exactly the kind of trench bully programs don’t casually replace.

The Lake Charles, Louisiana standout is ranked as the No. 20 overall player and No. 2 interior offensive lineman in the Rivals industry ranking.

At 6-3 and 295 pounds, Simien already looks like the kind of player built to survive SEC line-of-scrimmage wars.

That’s why Texas A&M pushed hard.

The Aggies offered Simien back in October 2024, got him to College Station multiple times, and hosted him for an official visit on June 12. For a while, A&M looked like a real factor.

Then Notre Dame got him on campus a week later, made its move, and closed the deal.

That’s recruiting at this level. It’s brutal, fast and rarely sentimental.

Still, let’s not pretend the sky is falling in Aggieland.

Texas A&M still has the No. 1 recruiting class in the country, and the Aggies’ offensive line haul remains nasty even without Simien.

The class already includes six five-star commitments, including elite offensive tackle Mark Matthews, the No. 5 player nationally, and interior offensive lineman Kennedy Brown, the No. 25 player in the country.

That’s not damage control. That’s a loaded room.

A&M also has four-star offensive tackles Kaeden Scott and DeMarrion Johnson in the fold, giving the Aggies real depth and flexibility up front.

Missing on Simien hurts, but it doesn’t create a crisis. It creates a headline.

There’s a difference.

The bigger picture is still wildly encouraging for Texas A&M. The Aggies have 23 commitments with an average rating of 91.27, which ranks fifth nationally and is the best among programs with 22 or more pledges. That’s not just volume. That’s volume with teeth.

Notre Dame, sitting right behind A&M nationally, landed a major piece and narrowed the perception gap.

Recruiting rankings are bragging rights until they become Saturdays, but momentum is real, and the Irish just grabbed some.

For Texas A&M, the response matters now.

Elite recruiting classes aren’t built by winning every battle. Nobody does that. They’re built by stacking enough elite wins that the misses don’t wreck the blueprint.

MORE: Aggies Draw Loaded 2027 College Classic Slate

Right now, the Aggies still have the blueprint. They still have the top class. They still have high-end offensive line talent coming.

But Simien’s decision is a reminder that staying No. 1 is harder than getting there.

Notre Dame just landed a five-star body blow. Now Texas A&M has to keep swinging.

Join Our Roundtable Community For Free!

Share your takes, connect with our Roundtable writers, and talk sports with fellow fans. Download the free Roundtable App today and stay closer to the conversation.