Nov 15, 2026 8:47 PM

Jayden Maiava’s struggles in Indiana dashed USC’s postseason hopes, leaving the Trojans to salvage their season as the young quarterback fights to prove he can handle elite defenses.

Last week, I wrote the following: If the Jayden Maiava who showed up in State College, handled the hostile environment, and threw for 300 yards and three touchdowns makes an appearance in Bloomington, Indiana, USC wins this game. Conversely, if the Maiava who came off a bye week and headed to Madison, Wisconsin, shows up, things could get ugly again.

Unfortunately, we got the latter.

I'm not trying to put the entire outcome of this game on Maiava's shoulders. However, this was one of those moments when he needed to prove he could do more than simply handle a difficult road environment. He needed to demonstrate that he could perform against a quality opponent with a tenacious defense.

I'm sure you've heard by now that USC's playoff hopes are over in 2026. The Trojans lost to Indiana 27-13, and there's more than enough blame to go around.

Related stories

However, despite all the mistakes and missed opportunities, Maiava still had an opportunity to change the outlook of this game. USC was trailing just 20-13 with roughly six and a half minutes remaining. That's when Jayden threw his second interception of the afternoon, essentially closing the door on the Trojans' chances of pulling off the upset.

And I want to be clear.

I'm not forgetting about the four interception opportunities USC's defense failed to capitalize on. Nor can I overlook the two missed field goals and eight penalties that accounted for 81 yards. However, through all of that, the team's leader failed to elevate his teammates and make the plays USC desperately needed.

This wasn't Jayden Maiava's first rodeo.

He's been under the guidance of the so-called QB Whisperer, Lincoln Riley, for three years. He's also been USC's starting quarterback for the last two seasons after taking over for the final four games of 2024, when Riley finally benched Miller Moss for many of the same reasons.

Remember? When the pressure was at its highest, and USC needed its quarterback to remain calm, cool, and collected, Moss often did the opposite. Costly mistakes became part of the problem, and Riley eventually made the decision to turn the page.

So, what's changed since 2024?

Actually, quite a lot.

Lincoln Riley has gone through another defensive coordinator and brought in Gary Patterson. There's been a noticeable difference on that side of the ball. Is it perfect? No. But it's getting closer to the standard expected at USC.

The roster has been upgraded with better players.

The Bloom Football Performance Center has opened.

And, overall, there's a sense that the program is in a much better place than it was five years ago when Riley took over.

None of the is in dispute, and Riley deserves credit for much of it.

What hasn't changed, though, is Riley's apparent difficulty recognizing when a player is no longer getting the job done. Or his tendency to remain loyal to players and coaches until it becomes too late to make a difference.

At what point will Riley tell his veteran quarterback that it's time to turn over the reins to Sam Huard or Jonas Williams, the same way he eventually did with Miller Moss?

And at what point will Riley's own future with the program come into question if he continues to let loyalty get in the way of making difficult decisions?

With the playoffs now off the table, there's no longer a reason to postpone evaluating what comes next. USC has nothing left to gain by continuing to run out the same lineup if the coaching staff believes there are better options for the future.

This is the time to find out what the younger quarterbacks can do. Give them meaningful snaps, let them learn, and determine whether one of them can become the answer moving forward.

Lincoln Riley needs to start coaching for USC's future, not simply trying to salvage what's left of the present.

Because right now, it's not just Jayden Maiava's future that's in question.

Lincoln Riley's future at USC is, too.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy