Bleacher Report's most recent rankings recognize multiple 49er gunslingers on their Top 100 Quarterbacks of All-Time list.
When Bleacher Report released its all-time quarterback rankings, the enduring legacy of the San Francisco 49ers was impossible to miss.
Six quarterbacks connected to the franchise appeared on the list, reflecting decades of elite play at one of football’s most important positions.
At the top of that group sits Joe Montana, ranked No. 2 overall. Montana’s career defined championship poise, highlighted by four Super Bowl victories and countless late-game heroics.
His accuracy, composure, and command of the offense helped shape how modern quarterbacks are evaluated. Even decades later, his clutch reputation remains a benchmark for postseason excellence.
Not far behind was Steve Young at No. 9. Taking over after Montana was no easy task, but Young ultimately built a Hall of Fame résumé of his own.
His mobility added a dynamic element to San Francisco’s offense, while his efficiency as a passer made him one of the most productive quarterbacks of the 1990s.
Young’s MVP seasons and Super Bowl success ensured his place among the game’s elite.
Earlier franchise history also earned recognition through Y.A. Tittle, who landed at No. 36. Tittle helped push pro football further into the passing era during his time in San Francisco.
Though he later reached even greater statistical heights elsewhere, his contributions with the 49ers remain an important chapter in the team’s early development.
Another longtime franchise figure, John Brodie, came in at No. 64. Brodie spent his entire career in San Francisco, providing stability and leadership through changing roster eras.
His 1970 MVP season stands as a high point before the franchise’s eventual dynasty years, and his longevity made him one of the most respected quarterbacks of his time.
The rankings also acknowledged more recent contributors. Jeff Garcia, ranked No. 74, revitalized the team around the turn of the century.
Undrafted out of college, Garcia became a Pro Bowl quarterback whose toughness and playmaking kept the team competitive during a transitional period.
Close behind was Alex Smith at No. 76. Smith’s career arc in San Francisco included early struggles followed by impressive growth.
His efficiency, leadership, and reduced turnover rate helped restore credibility to the franchise and laid the groundwork for future playoff runs.
Taken together, these six quarterbacks highlight a remarkable continuum of talent. From pioneering passers to championship legends and modern stabilizers, San Francisco’s quarterback lineage remains one of the richest traditions in NFL history.