Why Mike Florio Thinks the 49ers Are Playing Small Ball With Brandon Aiyuk
Nov 20, 2026 1:00 PM

Mike Florio says the 49ers’ drawn-out handling of Brandon Aiyuk looks petty and argues San Francisco should release the reinstated receiver now instead of running out the clock.

The Brandon Aiyuk saga has dragged on for more than a year, and Mike Florio has seen enough of it.

The ProFootballTalk founder has spent the past several weeks criticizing the San Francisco 49ers' handling of the end of their relationship with the receiver.

His point is simple: everybody knows how this ends, so the 49ers should stop stretching it out and let Aiyuk go.

The NFL reinstated Aiyuk from the reserve/left squad list on November 9, a move that began when the 49ers placed him there last December after months of friction with the front office.

Related stories

Reinstatement didn’t make Aiyuk a free agent. It sent him back to San Francisco with a two-week roster exemption, which lets the 49ers keep him in limbo without owing him a dime until the exemption runs out on November 24.

Florio has noted that the team has shown no interest in cutting Aiyuk before it absolutely has to. In his words, the 49ers “surely will kick the can as long as they can.”

Petty Optics Over Practical Purpose

Florio’s frustration isn’t really about the money, because the exemption already protects the 49ers’ wallet. He’s frustrated that waiting doesn’t get the team anything.

Alongside former Patriots star Devin McCourty, Florio argued that the decision has already been made and that holding on to a player the team clearly doesn’t want just looks petty and small.

He wondered whether the 49ers’ anger is really aimed at Aiyuk, or at themselves for never finding a trade before his value collapsed. Earlier in the process, Florio described the 49ers and the league office as squeezing Aiyuk.

He pointed out that the NFL waited until November 9, after his October 27 filing, to reinstate him, and that the union stayed quiet the whole time.

His advice was blunt: cut the guy today.

McCourty agreed, saying San Francisco is in a strong enough position to focus on its own season while giving Aiyuk a fresh start somewhere else.

Florio also asked fans to show some grace toward a player whose behavior has been easy to mock from a distance.

Washington Still Looms as the Landing Spot

Once Aiyuk is free, Florio believes all signs point to the Washington Commanders. Washington is still alive in the NFC East race and needs receivers after losing Terry McLaurin for the season.

Aiyuk has also reportedly patched things up with Jayden Daniels after their offseason social media dispute.

For the 49ers, that outcome is about as painless as it gets, since they’ve already beaten Washington and wouldn’t face a reunion in a playoff race.

Aiyuk hasn’t played since tearing his ACL and MCL against Kansas City in October 2024. Reports also say he owes the 49ers roughly $13 million in forfeited bonuses, which complicates his return.

Kyle Shanahan has already said publicly that the reinstatement means nothing to his team. Florio argues that if the 49ers truly feel that way, they should act on it and end this now rather than waiting until the last possible day.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy