The Dolphins’ reset has sparked Bills discussion, but only one of Tyreek Hill or Bradley Chubb makes real sense.
The Buffalo Bills don’t have the luxury of treating this offseason like a free-for-all talent grab.
With their salary cap situation, every move they make has to be about fixing specific problems, not adding names that look good on paper. The window is still open, but it’s admittedly a bit tighter now. The roster is older in some spots, the cap is less forgiving, and there are question marks at a number of positions.
That means needs matter more than splash.
When you look at Buffalo, honestly, the priorities aren’t hard to identify. They need to protect Josh Allen better. They need more consistency on defense when it matters most. And they need players who raise the team in January, not just the ceiling in September.
That’s why conversations linking the Bills to big-name skill players tend to miss the point.
This is where the discussion around two, now former, Miami Dolphins players gets interesting, not because either one is likely, but because of what the contrast says about what Buffalo should actually be chasing.
Tyreek Hill is the kind of name that instantly grabs attention. He’s been explosive and game-breaking for years, and still one of the most dangerous receivers in football. But once you get past the highlight factor, it’s hard to make it work based on the history and where Hill stands as a player right now.
Hill is coming off a serious knee injury that could see him miss most or all of the 2026 season. And, as a player whose speed was a major aspect of his game, that could lead to problems.
The reality is that speed-based stars don’t often age quietly. When decline starts, it tends to be sudden, and the Bills aren’t in a position to absorb that kind of risk.
The contract, the attention, and the ripple effect across the roster all point to this being more of a headline move than a football one.
Bradley Chubb, on the other hand, fits the conversation in a way Hill doesn’t.
That doesn’t mean he’s a perfect solution. Chubb’s injury history matters—two torn ACLs over the years—, and it would have to be central to any real evaluation. But when he’s been healthy, he’s shown he can consistently affect games at a position the Bills have been trying to stabilize for years.
Buffalo’s pass rush has been good in stretches, but it hasn’t always been dependable when the stakes are highest. They’ve had to scheme pressure, rotate heavily, and rely on timing rather than dominance. A healthy Chubb changes that equation. He forces protections to slide. He creates opportunities for everyone else up front. And he addresses a need that shows up every postseason.
Financially, it’s also an easier sell. Investing in the defensive line aligns with how playoff games are won. It’s not flashy, but it’s practical, and the Bills are at a point where practicality matters.
This isn’t about just wanting one player and rejecting another. It’s about understanding what the Bills actually need to move forward.
They don’t need noise. They need answers.
And if this offseason is going to be about correcting course rather than chasing excitement, it’s clear which type of player fits that plan and which one doesn’t.
Bills Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Bills. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.