Failure to reach the postseason would trigger intense scrutiny of Brandon Beane’s roster construction and Joe Brady’s leadership as Buffalo grapples with high expectations and a closing window.
The Buffalo Bills are a team where simply making the playoffs isn't good enough. Hell, neither is just winning the AFC East and a playoff game or two.
They've made the playoffs in seven-straight seasons, won five AFC East titles, and have been to multiple AFC Championship games. At this point, they're expected to be there and in contention for a Super Bowl.
But what happens if they aren't? What happens if the Bills don't even make the playoffs?
It's not a likely outcome, but it's also not impossible. This isn't a scenario where Josh Allen suffers a season-ending injury in Week 2, so take that out of the equation. Imagine Allen stays healthy, but the Bills struggle through one of the league's tougher schedules, lose a couple of games they should win, and finish 9-8 or 10-7. For the first time since 2018, Buffalo is watching the postseason from home.
The immediate reaction would be to look for someone to blame.
Brandon Beane would almost certainly be at the center of that conversation. As the architect of the roster, every decision he made over the past several years would come under the microscope. Fans would question whether the Bills have done enough to surround Allen with the right pieces, whether certain draft picks should have worked out differently, and whether the front office has been aggressive enough while its franchise quarterback remains in his prime.
Even so, I don't believe Beane's job would be in danger despite the calls for it from fans.
The Bills recently promoted him to president of football operations, a move that reinforced the organization's confidence in his long-term vision. Teams don't make that type of commitment only to reverse course after one disappointing season. What a playoff miss would do, however, is increase the urgency surrounding every decision moving forward.
The same applies to Joe Brady.
If Buffalo misses the postseason in his first year as head coach, there would undoubtedly be criticism. That's unavoidable when expectations are as high as they are in Buffalo. At the same time, it would be difficult to justify moving on after one full season unless the year completely unraveled. The Bills hired Brady believing he could lead this team into its next chapter, and one disappointing season shouldn't erase that belief.
The bigger story wouldn't be who loses a job.
It would be why the Bills fell short.
Did the defense fail to take the step everyone expected under Jim Leonhard? Did the pass rush never become the dominant unit it looked capable of being on paper? Did questions at linebacker eventually catch up to the defense? Or was it simply a case of losing too many close games against one of the NFL's toughest schedules?
Those answers would shape the offseason far more than the final record itself.
One thing I don't expect is a complete teardown.
As long as Allen is under center, the Bills will view themselves as contenders. You don't spend years searching for a quarterback of his caliber only to pivot toward rebuilding after one disappointing season. Instead, the focus would shift toward identifying exactly what kept a championship-caliber roster from reaching the postseason and fixing it as quickly as possible.
Missing the playoffs wouldn't close Buffalo's Super Bowl window. It would simply create more pressure than the franchise has faced in years, because for the first time in a long time, the Bills wouldn't just be trying to take the next step.
Bills Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Bills. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.
