Nobody is expecting much for the 2026 Cleveland Browns. As things stand ahead training camp next month, Cleveland is a team with a young core, in the middle of a rebuild, with a big question mark at quarterback and a first-time head coach. 

That's considered by most to be the perfect recipe for a team that will experience plenty of growing pains this fall and therefore some not-so-great results on the field. But what if things go better than expected? Or what if everything clicks with this young group sooner than initially thought? 

Those outcomes would help produce the best-case scenario for this year's iteration of the Browns. There's also a world where the franchise is held back by its youth, though, which would likely produce the worst-case scenario. 

Here's what both of those look like. 

Both the best and the worst-case scenarios start with the question of what level of QB play the Browns will get in 2026? For the former outcome, they need one of Deshaun Watson or Shedeur Sanders to produce above-average QB play, turning one of the NFL's worst offenses last season into one that can legitimately hang with anyone. The quarterback play needs to lift this offense up, not hold it back.

Meanwhile, a new rookie class that features Spencer Fano, KC Concepcion, Denzel Boston, Emmanuel McNeil-Warren follows in the footsteps of last year's class featuring Mason Graham, Carson Schwesinger, Quinshon Judkins and Harold Fannin Jr. in being immediately impactful players. If those guys, and some other new additions, click quickly and this young core is ready to shoulder a heavy workload, the sky is the limit for Cleveland. 

On defense, there's a moderate step back after losing the best non-quarterback in football in Myles Garrett, but it remains a top 10 unit overall. Jared Verse prevents a major dropoff in production at defensive end by putting together his past season. 

All those things have the Browns prominently "in the hunt" come December, and potentially sneaking into the playoffs if things go right in the home stretch of the season. 

Quarterback play takes center stage again, but in this case, neither Watson or Sanders emerges as a competent starter. The former may start the season under center, but find himself benched after several weeks, or injured, as the same inconsistent play that has plagued him since coming to Cleveland continues. 

Sanders takes over, and while there are noticeable improvements in his footwork and processing, the on-field results continue to fall short and the offense sputters because of it. 

That young core of players may flash some noteworthy moments that prove they'll be impactful down the line, but the growing pains of a young team are evident. In key moments of the game, that inexperience shows up and proves costly, as that promising core simply isn't ready to carry the team just yet. 

Meanwhile, without Garrett to uplift the defense and a new voice in charge of it, the entire group takes a major step back, sliding out of the top half of the league overall.

With the defense no longer carrying Cleveland, and the offense still figuring things out, the team is largely non-competitive week-after-week and finishes with five or fewer wins for a third straight season. 

The reality of the 2026 Cleveland Browns is probably somewhere in the middle of both of those scenarios. There are tangible reasons to believe that the quarterback play could be improved from a year ago (the bar is very low) if for nothing else than the fact that the environment around the quarterbacks figures to be better this year. 

That starts up front in the trenches, where Cleveland rebuilt the entire o-line, and extends to the skill positions where two new rookie receivers join the fold, and expectations are high for returning youngsters like Judkins and Fannin Jr. 

Still, the new-look offensive line needs to mesh successfully, and these young players, the offense is counting on to have an immediate impact, will probably face plenty of ups and downs throughout the season (not every player can be Carson Schwesinger upon entering the league). 

The defense is also surely due for some regression with Garrett gone and some philosophical changes from Mike Rutenberg. That's okay, but nobody should be expecting that unit to drag the Browns to wins the way it tried to in each of the last two seasons. 

With so much new, from the coaching staff down through key areas of the roster, the reality of this year's Browns is that they're a young football team, with major questions at the most important position and a lot of changes to overcome.

That doesn't mean they can't be good, but it does mean they're probably not a playoff team either. 5-7 wins feel like the sweet spot for a Browns team building its way back into being a true contender. 

Browns Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Browns. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.