Tom Brady Didn't Sugarcoat Justin Herbert's Interception in Week 3
Sep 29, 2026 12:00 PM

Justin Herbert threw an interception against the Bills, and Tom Brady didn't hold back on the Fox broadcast.

Some quarterback mistakes need a long film session to explain. Justin Herbert's interception against the Bills on Sunday took Tom Brady three short sentences.

Calling the Los Angeles Chargers and Buffalo Bills game for Fox with Kevin Burkhardt, Brady watched the replay of Herbert trying to hit Marquez Valdes-Scantling down the middle and pointed straight at what Herbert missed: C.J. Gardner-Johnson, sitting in the deep middle of the field.

His verdict was about as cutting as analysis gets: "Poor awareness. Poor decision. Throws him a meatball sub."

The sandwich line drew the laughs, but the first two sentences are the ones that Herbert should take constructively.

Related stories

Reading the Middle of the Field

One of the first things a quarterback learns to check before the snap is whether the middle of the field is open or closed.

If there's a safety sitting deep in the middle, throws down the seam get very dangerous, because that defender is in position to break on anything thrown his way. Beating that look usually means holding the safety with your eyes, taking the ball outside, or checking it down.

That's what Brady meant by "poor awareness." He wasn't calling it a bad throw or bad luck. He was saying the read went wrong before the ball was ever released. From a quarterback who won seven Super Bowls largely by knowing where every safety was, that's about as pointed as criticism gets.

For anyone who hasn't spent the fall on social media: "meatball sub" has become the go-to name for an interception that falls entirely on the quarterback.

Baseball fans have long used "meatball" to describe a hittable pitch thrown right down the middle, and football fans have borrowed the term for a pass that basically delivers itself to a defender.

Hearing it from Brady on a national broadcast was a sign that the joke has gone fully mainstream.

Why It Matters for Herbert

Herbert has never had trouble with the physical part of the job. His arm strength and ability to make difficult throws have been obvious since his Oregon days.

The ongoing debate about him has been whether his decision-making under pressure matches his talent. A play like this one feeds that debate, and having Brady break it down on national TV makes it louder.

To be fair, one interception doesn't define a quarterback, and every great passer, Brady included, has thrown some that looked just as bad.

The difference is how often it happens. Elite quarterbacks keep these mistakes rare, and they learn from each one.

This is also a reminder of what Brady offers in the booth. He's at his best when he stops being polite and talks like a quarterback evaluating another quarterback. He doesn't hedge, and he doesn't blame the receiver or the line when the problem was the read.

Herbert will get plenty more chances this season to show the pick was an outlier, but on Sunday, the greatest quarterback ever looked at the replay, saw the safety Herbert didn't, and named the mistake in a way fans won't forget soon.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy