Anthony Richardson's 2024 Revealed As Historically Poor

Pro Football Focus recently released a list of the most and least accurate passing seasons by quarterbacks in PFF history, using its tracking data.

Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson Sr., infamously, had a 47.7% completion percentage on the season, which was a single-season franchise low, but it actually gets worse.

A shocking 33.6% of Richardson's passes were considered uncatchable, which is the worst mark in PFF history. Richardson's adjusted completion percentage of 60.2% is also the worst since Tim Tebow in 2011. Adjusted completion percentage removes intentional throwaways and drops to show a "true" completion percentage.

"The 2024 season was a very trying one for Richardson, who tallied a 59.8 PFF passing grade while being benched," PFF wrote. "The linchpin of Richardson’s problems was his accuracy, as he was well off the mark more than any other quarterback since 2015. It may not be a shock to learn that Richardson’s 60.2% adjusted completion percentage is the worst among quarterbacks with at least 200 dropbacks since Tim Tebow in 2011.

"A raw but tantalizing prospect coming out of Florida, Richardson remains a flawed passer but has yet to earn a sufficient number of reps — garnering only 399 dropbacks across his three career seasons," PFF continued. "With Daniel Jones back in the saddle in Indianapolis, the former fourth overall pick doesn’t have a clear runway to better his accuracy in 2026 and may need to depart the Colts for a fresh opportunity."