Nov 18, 2026 6:18 PM

The Indianapolis Colts should make Grover Stewart one of their few in-house free-agent priorities next offseason.

Should any Indianapolis Colts free agents be a priority?More Videos

The Indianapolis Colts moved on from four expiring contracts at the trade deadline in an effort to gain compensation for players who were unlikely to be re-signed after the season. The process makes sense, but if that was the case, why is 33-year-old defensive tackle Grover Stewart still on the team?

Stewart was drafted in the fourth round of the 2017 NFL Draft by the Colts and has spent his entire career with the organization. He signed a three-year, $30.75 million extension in 2020 and another three-year deal (this time for $39 million) in 2024. His next contract will be his fourth, and potentially his last, in the NFL. 

Timeline-wise, re-signing Stewart doesn’t make a ton of sense for the Colts. He is nearing the end of his career while the team is entering a rebuild this offseason. Teams can turn around situations quickly, but with the Colts lacking a first-round pick and a viable path to acquiring a quarterback, it seems unlikely the Colts will be a true contender in the near future. 

All of that being said, I believe that the Colts should absolutely re-sign the veteran defensive tackle this offseason (if he’s interested).

Related stories

The Colts are set to have nearly $80 million in cap space this offseason, and that’s without releasing players under contract to free up even more room. The team has to pay somebody, and why not shell out some cap space for a beloved player and a key veteran on the team?

The Colts were notorious under former general manager Chris Ballard for re-signing players because of their presence in the locker room, so I understand that it will take a bit more convincing to get Colts fans on board with bringing back the veteran defensive tackle. Despite being near the end of his career, Stewart is still playing excellent football at the moment. 

According to Sumer Sports, Stewart is tied for fourth among all defensive tackles with eight run stuffs and is tied for 12th with 15 run stops this season. He’s also contributed more as a pass rusher in recent years, adding more pressures to his game and ranking third among all defensive tackles in pass deflections per 100 snaps at 2.29 this season. 

The more notable aspect of his play, though, is the Colts’ run defense when he is on the field vs. when he is off the field. When Stewart is on the field, the Colts allow just 4.5 yards per carry, hold opponents to a 6.7% explosive run rate, and allow a 42.1% rush success rate. When Stewart is off the field, the Colts allow 5.11 yards per carry, hold opponents to a 9.6% explosive run rate, and allow a 46.6% rush success rate.

Stewart is not only a stable veteran who is loved in the locker room, but he is also one of the better run-defending defensive tackles in the league and is immensely valuable to the Colts’ run defense. As the Colts enter a new era of a rebuild, it would be wise to have a capable veteran for younger players to look up to and a guy who can serve as a placeholder at defensive tackle while younger players develop. 

In my opinion, there is no downside to re-signing Stewart this offseason. He should absolutely be brought back to finish out his career with the Colts next offseason.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy