Nov 17, 2026 11:00 AM
Grading how the Washington Commanders' rookie class has fared at roughly the halfway point of the 2026 regular season
The Washington Commanders have watched several new and familiar names step up at points during the 2026 regular season, but what about the six selections from the 2026 NFL Draft? Grading how they've fared midway through the season.
Sonny Styles, LB (round 1, Pick 7): A
After drawing unwarranted criticism in limited preseason snaps, the Ohio State product has lived up to expectations. Styles leads the team and ranks tied for tenth across the NFL with 80 total tackles this season while he's already made his impact in both pass and run coverage. Styles has built an impressive case to be the Defensive Rookie of the Year selection and shown flashes of becoming the anchor that the Commanders' defense needs in the future.
Antonio Williams, WR (round 3, Pick 71): A-
Related stories
The Clemson product has made the most of his snaps, reeling in 28 of his 41 targets. Williams ranks second on the team in both catches (28) and receiving yards (326) while he notched one of the three touchdowns in the last-second win over the New York Giants, marking his second of the season against an NFC East defense. The 2027 wide receiver room will need to be addressed with Terry McLaurin coming off a significant injury and Stefon Diggs on a one year deal, but Williams has shown capable of being part of the foundation.
Joshua Josephs, EDGE (round 5, Pick 147): C
The day three pick has appeared in all but one game in 2026 where he's been part of the outside linebacker rotation, though his production has been limited. After logging five tackles and one stuff in the week three win agains the Seattle Seahawks, Josephs has logged five total tackles over the last six games and struggled to put pressure on opposing quarterbacks across his limited reps. Josephs has not drawn more than 28% of defensive snaps in any game this season, including just 12 reps through the first three regular season games.
Kaytron Allen, RB (round 6, Pick 187): N/A
The lone incomplete due to the fact that his short-lived tenure ended with the Commanders waiving him and Miami Dolphins swooping in to claim him, ending his tenure with just 41 yards on 12 carries. His final snap ultimately injured right guard Sam Cosmi, while the writing was on the wall when Washington turned to Craig Reynolds over Allen on a critical fourth down in the week four loss against the Indianapolis Colts. A disappointing stint ended in a perplexing roster decision, reason enough for the incomplete grade.
Matt Gulbin, C (round 6, Pick 209): B-
The Michigan State and Wake Forest product has been part of the ongoing questions at center. After not appearing in the regular season opener, Gulbin rotated in during both weeks two and three before starting at right guard in week four. He then didn't appear in another game until he took over at center for Lucas Patrick in the second half in week nine. Head coach Dan Quinn then turned to Nick Allegretti as the starter in the week ten win against the Giants with Gulbin in the backup role and Patrick sidelined due to a concussion. The in-game development plan has been questionable along the way, similar to Allen, while he's allowed one sack and two pressures across four appearances.
Athan Kaliakmanis, QB (round 7, Pick 223): C+
After stepping in as the emergency quarterback nearly every week, the Commanders' final pick from the draft proved to have value after stepping in for an injured Marcus Mariota against Indianapolis in week four, throwing for 186 yards including a 48-yard touchdown while completing 45.5% of his attempts. Though it came in a losing effort in a game where injuries and penalties loomed large, Kaliakmanis showed signs of confidence in why he can elevate the floor of the room. Marcus Mariota has completed nearly 65% of his attempts in his third season with the organization, but whether Kaliakmanis can ultimately do enough to become the primary backup in 2027 will be the question ahead.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


