Nov 16, 2026 2:36 AM
Updated Nov 16, 2026 2:40 PM
A historic defensive collapse and questionable coaching decisions leave Dallas reeling at 4-6, forcing a frustrated Dak Prescott to demand immediate answers amid a spiraling season.
Even by the Dallas Cowboys' sorry standards, this was as shocking as it was sad.
During a 46-40 shootout loss to the San Francisco 49ers at AT&T Stadium on Sunday, the Cowboys’ defense was bullied and bludgeoned for more yards than any visiting team in the franchise’s once-proud 67-year history.
With the game still on the line, the Cowboys employed a "crafty scheme'' by blitzing and putting a 37-year-old defensive end in man-to-man coverage against one of the fastest running backs in the NFL.
And while attempting a frantic fourth-quarter rally where yards and seconds were precious, one of their egomaniacal offensive stars received a 15-yard penalty for taunting.
Related stories
This team is pitiful. This team is poorly-coached. This team, fittingly, is 4-6 and headed nowhere fast.
My Top 10 Whitty Observations:
10. SILVER LINING – Well, at least the Cowboys didn’t get penalized for having a bench player in “blue sweats and a stocking cap” run on to the field.
Small, minuscule steps in the right direction, folks.
9. SAD STAT – Coordinator Christian Parker’s horrendous defense was typically, well, horrendous.
Or, rather, "atrocious,'' as head coach Brian Schottenheimer phrased it.
When San Francisco scored on its opening drive of the third quarter to build a 24-16 lead, it marked the 17th consecutive game Dallas’ defense has allowed 20+ points. It’s the longest streak in franchise history and the longest in the NFL in five years.
Some perspective on just how out-of-whack the Cowboys are: In each of their five Super Bowl seasons their defense held at least nine opponents under 20.
8. DAK DEPRESSING – Your quarterback throws for 343 yards and five touchdowns and in almost every case your team is going to win. These, however, are the 2026 Cowboys, who have now lost games despite scoring 31, 30 and 40 points.
This is Dak Prescott’s seventh career loss at home when scoring 30+ points.
When Tom Brady scored 30 points at home over his 23-year career, his record was 60-2.
Said Prescott after the game: “I do truly believe that we have the people, but something’s gotta change.”
My response: a) No, you do not "have the people.'' And b) "Change what''? What are you even talking about?
7. WHAT THE WHAT? – Never ever never is it a good time to assign 37-year-old defensive end Von Miller to cover speedy running back Christian McCaffrey one on one. It’s especially preposterous when you’re only down six points late in the game and need a stop to get the ball back.
Predictably, McCaffrey easily shook Miller and raced untouched for a 66-yard catch-and-run touchdown that put the game out of reach at 46-32.
I get it; you're blitzing. But why not have the future Hall-of-Famer Miller as a rusher rather than as a back-pedaller?
I’ve used this term before, and it’s becoming a recurring theme with this staff: Coaching Malpractice.
6. PRESCOTT'S POKE – The QB took a subtle shot at Cowboys fans who didn't come to AT&T Stadium, choosing instead to sell their tickets to 49ers fans who pretty much took over the building.
I can do a deep analysis of why a season-ticket holder might pass on attending this game, but for now, I'll go this way:
Maybe Dak and his teammates should worry about how to "play,'' and let the fans worry about how to "fan,'' OK?
5. TELLING TRAIT – The Cowboys fall to 1-4 when trailing at the half. Not sure if that’s a sign of being simply a bad football team or also being poorly coached … or both.
Meanwhile, this head coach is now 11-15-1 during his time here.
What was that word, Schotty? Oh, yeah.
"Atrocious.''
4. INSTANT CLASSIC? – It’s not often a quarterback (Brock Purdy) finishes with barely more incompletions (six) than sacks (five), but there was a lot of weirdness – and entertainment – in this one. The combined 86 points and 1,023 yards are the most in the series’ 42-game history.
Maybe I’ll have to sneak it into my Top 10 most memorable Cowboys-49ers games after all.
3. “ME” OVER “WE” – For a 4-6 team, the Cowboys sure have an annoying knack of over-celebrating.
It started with Javonte Williams’ taunting penalty in the season opener when trailing the Giants late, continued with Overshown in Indy last week, and reared its ugly head again in this one with George Pickens’ ill-timed selfish act.
Sure the talented receiver caught three touchdowns, but again and again he prioritized “me” over “we.”
With his team desperately trying to mount a comeback but down 14 points with under two minutes remaining, Pickens caught a pass and after the whistle – with the clock running, mind you – spent a couple seconds flexing because a 49ers’ defender was unable to tackle him to the ground.
On the very next play, he caught an 11-yard pass on the sideline but then barked and pointed at 49ers’ cornerback Deommodore Lenoir to draw a 15-yard taunting penalty.
Good football teams don’t do that. Good teammates don’t do that.
These acts are stupid and selfish and are signs of a lack of discipline under this coach - and under owner Jerry Jones.
2. DUMBSDAY DEFENSE – When they weren’t running over and through Dallas’ defense, the Niners were running circles around it.
Kalelon Black embarrassingly abused Cowboys’ defenders Caleb Downs and Cobie Durant like tackling dummies on his 25-yard, third-quarter touchdown run.
Said Schottenheimer: "We tackled like shit in the second half.”
Additionally, Parker’s pathetic unit coughed up another eye-popping amount of explosive plays. They surrendered receiving touchdowns - untouched, mind you - to Christian McCaffrey of 74 and 66 yards and a 70-yard reverse run to Deebo Samuel.
Those three, on the heels of giving up 50+-yard plays to guys named Tyler Allgeier and Ashton Dulin in recent weeks.
With all the open space and gaudy stats, if you didn’t know better you’d think the Cowboys were playing six-man football in a small Texas town on a Friday night.
1. REVENGE, SERVED IN RED – Dallas surrendered three touchdowns of 65+ yards, 46 points and a record 584 yards.
Adding to the Cowboys embarrassment: Do you know who holds the 49ers title of 'Assistant Head Coach/Defense?
That would be ... Matt Eberflus.
2
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy



