Nov 20, 2026 4:08 PM

At this point, the Cowboys defense is so bad - "New York Life''-bad, Washington Generals-bed - you have to laugh, to keep from crying.

FRISCO - Let's rank the most pathetically incompetent defenses in the history of America:

1952 Washington Generals - The Harlem Globetrotters create a fake fodder opponent - the “Washington Generals ” - who regularly lose games by 50+ points and play the foil in every comic ruse.

1974 New York Life Opponent - Insurance giant New York Life launches a TV ad campaign during NFL games, in which its clients - in street clothes, no less - run circles around around an anonymous, incompetent team of maroon-and-gold-clad defenders who haplessly flop, flail and fall on the field.

2021 Sovereign Citizen - On trial for driving his SUV through a Wisconsin Christmas parade and killing six people, Darrell Brooks Jr. receives six life sentences without parole after representing himself and presenting a cockamamie defense suggesting the court had no jurisdiction over him as a “sovereign citizen.”

Related stories

2026 Dallas Cowboys - In one of the worst defensive performances in NFL history, coordinator Christian Parker’s clueless crew not only surrenders 46 points and 584 yards to the San Francisco 49ers but in doing so allows three, untouched touchdowns of 65+ yards, produces a Keystone Cops routine chasing ghosts on a reverse, and laughably deploys a 37-year-old defensive end in man-to-man pass coverage against one of fastest, best receiving receiving running backs in the league.

Yes, they’re that bad. 

As I wrote last week, the Cowboys have never won a Super Bowl without a top-five defense. Their defensive rankings the last three seasons: 28th, 30th and, now, dead-last 32nd.

Blame Dak Prescott all you want, but Dallas gives up the league’s most rushing yards and total yards per game and only the Arizona Cardinal and Las Vegas Raiders allow more points. The Cowboys have lost games this season scoring 30, 31 and 40 points.

The inglorious incompetence isn’t for a lack of trying, at least in terms of a constant churning of personnel.

In 2020 the Cowboys had the then-worst defense in franchise history. That unit coughed up 6,183 yards and 473 points in a performance that got coordinator Mike Nolan fired after one season. After three relatively successful years under Dan Quinn, owner Jerry Jones has endured one-hit blunders with Mike Zimmer, Matt Eberflus and now Parker, who had his play-calling duties stripped this week in favor of consultant Mike Pettine.

There are no defensive players on the roster from 2020. There are no defensive coaches on the staff from 2020. How then, does this defense so resemble 2020? Or, for that matter 2013, when Tony Romo threw for 506 yards and five touchdowns and lost a game to the Denver Broncos, 51-48? The current nucleus of players has allowed 20+ points in a franchise-worst 17 consecutive games.

It’s as though the Cowboys have been defenseless since Jimmy Johnson left in 1994. Why? Consider the premium-pick defensive flops since his departure: Shante Carver (1994), Kavika Pittman (1996), Ebenezer Ekuban (1999), Dywane Goodrich (2000), Bobby Carpenter (2006), Jason Williams (2009), Morris Claiborne (2012), Byron Jones (2015), Taco Charlton (2017), Trysten Hill (2019) and Mazi Smith (2023).

We all know Jerry is the common-denominator talent evaluator. When we see Caleb Downs get trucked by the 49ers’ Kaelon Black last Sunday and defensive tackle Elijah Garcia furiously chasing a Niners’ runner 20 yards downfield although the ball had long been tossed to another player on a reverse 60 yards from him, it all lands in the lap of the stubborn general manager. 

Jerry tried a defensive makeover last offseason, but it’s just as ugly as all the one before it. It’s his Dumbsday Defense.

The 1970s birthed the Cowboys’ original Doomsday Defense with the likes of Hall of Famers Bob Lilly, Mel Renfro, Chuck Howley, Herb Adderly and Cliff Harris.

On the rare occasion that defense would miss a tackle, Dad and I would mockingly scream at the TV:

“C’mon New York Life!”

At this point, the Cowboys defense is so bad - "New York Life''-bad, Washington Generals-bed - you have to laugh, to keep from crying.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy