May 29, 2026 5:00 PM
The Atlanta Falcons’ quarterback battle between Tua Tagovailoa and Michael Penix Jr. continues to be one of the NFL’s most intriguing offseason storylines. With Kevin Stefanski leading a new era in Atlanta, the decision at QB1 could shape whether the Falcons finally end their long playoff drought.
The Atlanta Falcons have one of the most interesting quarterback battles this offseason across the entire league, with the free agent signing of Tua Tagovailoa and Michael Penix Jr., who is fighting back from an injury.
In this week's Falcons Roundtable, the staff takes a stab at some of the surrounding topics from the QB battle and, of course, our way-too-early predictions.
1.) Does each quarterback have enough weapons to be successful in 2026?
Michael Brauner: Without a doubt. Weapons are maybe the last thing on the list of potential problems for this team between Bijan Robinson in the running and pass game, Drake London, and Kyle Pitts Sr. to throw to, with a potential X-factor in Zachariah Branch out of the slot, whoever does win the job does not have much excuse if they are not getting it done at a high level for this offense early on.
Christian Rauh: If they believe in Zachariah Branch being a week 1 impactful player, then yes. However, I'm not completely sold. I still think the Falcons should make one more move, trade or free agency, and bring in a solid WR2 into the mix.
Zac Blackerby: I think the weapons are certainly there. We've seen other teams in the league succeed with much less. My major concern is the scheme and protecting whoever ends up as Atlanta's QB.
2.) Can the Falcons actually afford to let this quarterback battle play out deep into training camp, or do they need a clear QB1 early for the offense to develop chemistry?
MB: Having a defined QB1 would be ideal, but it's not worth rushing a decision in a race that likely is very close at this point. Both guys are learning a new system and doing everything they can to get better every day, so until someone clearly separates themselves, Atlanta does not gain a whole lot from naming a starter right now. By the middle of training camp, we should have a clearer idea.
CR: The season starts against a head coach trying to prove his worth to the Pittsburgh Steelers faithful, and Aaron Rodgers, who is on his NFL farewell tour this year. I think having the most important answer decided as soon as possible is definitely a smart idea.
ZB: I think there are pros and cons to both. I will say that if this franchise believes that Penix can be the face of this team for years to come, give the young QB as many reps as possible.
3.) Way too early prediction. Who do you expect to start week 1 vs. the Steelers?
MB: I did not expect to say this, but after a week of OTAs, I'm actually leaning slightly towards Tagovailoa right now. Between the way Stefanski has spoken about him and his accuracy, the fact that his health is not a question right now, and a proven ability to manage an offense with strong weapons before, Tagovailoa has the leg up for me. I don't think he's the QB of the future for this team, but Stefanski may feel he gives them the better chance to win now.
CR: If Penix is healthy, he's my pick. As much as I think Tua fits Stefanski's scheme and Matt Ryan will be looking to make an instant splash, it seems like you have to give the one you drafted a chance to make it right.
ZB: I'll say Penix is the guy week one.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


