The reporting keeps changing, the leverage keeps shifting, and the noise keeps getting louder. But through all of it, the same idea remains: A.J. Brown and the Patriots still look destined to find each other before this offseason is over.
Where there’s smoke, there’s fire.
And there’s been a whole lot of smoke on the A.J. Brown trade front. Not just this offseason, but in the years leading up to this moment.
Brown’s tenure with the Philadelphia Eagles has been a roller coaster — filled with the highest of highs and the lowest of lows. From winning a Super Bowl championship to reading books and getting into screaming matches with his head coach and quarterback on the sideline, the dichotomy of Brown’s experience in Philadelphia has made it a situation worth constantly monitoring.
Now, it appears we’ve reached an impasse.
Eagles General Manager Howie Roseman has been fielding phone calls from teams all offseason. Brown’s preferred destinations were reportedly short in length — the New England Patriots, Buffalo Bills, Kansas City Chiefs, and Los Angeles Chargers. And there’s only been one constant: New England.
Brown’s affinity for the Patriots shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone. He grew up a fan of the team, was visibly emotional when they passed on him to draft N’Keal Harry in the first round of the 2019 draft, and has been outspoken about his fandom throughout his professional career with other organizations.
New England’s reciprocation of that feeling is the NFL’s worst-kept secret right now.
Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel coached Brown during his first three seasons in the NFL with the Tennessee Titans, and has stayed in close contact with him since the two parted ways. More than just the game, it appears the two have developed a close interpersonal relationship that extends into their lives away from football.
The relationship is there, and so is the need for a player with Brown’s skill set — and that may be even more difficult to find.
New England has been consistently active in the “WR1” market for the better part of three years as it searches for the missing piece to pair with Drake Maye while he’s on an affordable rookie contract. It still hasn’t found it.
With Brown, a prolific “X” receiver is available — a specialist on the boundary who creates separation, finishes through contact at the catch point, and generates yards after the catch. He’s a downfield threat who can place stress on a defense at all three levels.
Once upon a time, the Patriots may not have put a lot of stock — or monetary value — into a receiver with that specific skill set. With Tom Brady at quarterback, Josh McDaniels’ offense ran through the middle of the field, in front of the sticks. Receivers like Julian Edelman and Wes Welker starred because of their ability to make quick decisions and read the field similarly to Brady, who was looking to release the ball quicker than the rush could reach him.
In 2025, McDaniels attempted that approach with veteran receiver Stefon Diggs, who assumed a primarily slot role and made his living sitting between zones as an always-available target for Maye. It worked, to an extent, as Diggs was hyper-efficient — leading the league with an 83.3% catch rate. But in the playoffs, that production evaporated, and New England had no counterpunch.
With Maye at quarterback, the Patriots are morphing into a downfield passing offense — one that stresses the defense deep to open up opportunities underneath, a reversal from their earlier century of success.
While there may once have been a premium on receivers like Edelman, Welker, and Danny Amendola in Foxboro, Maye’s style of quarterbacking places a heavier emphasis on boundary receivers who can consistently stress a defense over the top.
There aren’t many better options to fill that role than Brown, and the Patriots seem to be following suit with a shift in their philosophical approach to roster building.
Following the rush of free agency last week, New England filled many of the holes it entered the offseason with. And yet, there’s seemingly still room for Brown on the cap. After every signing — especially that of Romeo Doubs — there was almost a simultaneous report to go along with it: “this won’t impact their ability to acquire Brown.”
They’re waiting for him, and he’s waiting for them. So what’s the holdup?
As of now, there are two major factors affecting the timeline of a Brown trade — neither of which will affect where he lands, but rather when he arrives.
First is his contract, and that’s the more straightforward of the two. If dealt before June 1, Brown will account for over $43 million of dead cap for Philadelphia in 2026. Post-June 1, that number drops to just about $16 million.
Yeah, that’s a big difference.
But unlike what most would suggest, it doesn’t make trading Brown entirely impossible pre-June 1. Teams take on dead money with players every year, and oftentimes, it’s more than Brown’s cap hit. Just this year, the Miami Dolphins took on a $100 million dead cap hit to release — not trade — Tua Tagovailoa. The Arizona Cardinals just took a $55 million dead cap hit by releasing Kyler Murray. The Denver Broncos took on $85 million when they released Russell Wilson two years ago.
Yes, those teams were, or are, in a much different position than Philadelphia — which enters 2026 still feeling like its championship window is open. But it’s clear that, akin to those situations, Brown’s relationship with the organization is fractured beyond repair.
It’s harder to imagine Brown on the Eagles in 2026 than it is him getting dealt.
And that leads us to point number two, which makes this a much more interesting debate: compensation.
If Brown is too far gone to return to Philadelphia in 2026, the Eagles lose any leverage they have in negotiating a fair-market price for the receiver. That doesn’t jibe well with Roseman, who has made a career of “winning the deal.”
For an asset he once gave up a first- and third-round pick for, that’ll be even more difficult to do now. Four years removed from that trade, and Roseman’s reported asking price is — get this — a first- and second-round pick.
Typically, players involved in trades are treated like cars … depreciating assets. Four years older, with much more mileage, and Roseman is asking for more than he paid for. That’s not happening, and he knows it. But it won’t stop him from posturing.
He’s been able to do so to this point. Brown is under contract with the team, and for a large part of the offseason, New England reeked of desperation in acquiring him. It cut Stefon Diggs before free agency began and, when Alec Pierce re-signed with the Indianapolis Colts, lost all leverage it had to play Brown against a field of alternatives. The Patriots made a position of need weaker, and Brown was the clear play.
Until the signing of Romeo Doubs.
Doubs enters Foxboro as a potential top option in the passing game, and his arrival greatly reduces the feeling of desperation New England had for Brown just one week ago. If a trade doesn’t materialize, the Patriots could walk into the regular season content with where the receiver room stands as currently constructed. And that’s a big differentiating factor.
Now, the Patriots hold some cards to negotiate a much fairer price for Brown — just as the Eagles have run out of alternatives.
The Buffalo Bills traded a second-round pick for former Chicago Bears wide receiver D.J. Moore (woof). They’re out. The Los Angeles Chargers invested heavily in edge rusher and offensive line. They’re out. The Kansas City Chiefs have been doing cap gymnastics in an attempt to retain even some of their star players around Patrick Mahomes. They’re out.
Every few days, a new report seems to state that New England is the only team left in the running. And each time that happens, a new team “enters the chat.”
This past weekend, the Los Angeles Rams were “sniffing” around the market for Brown before reportedly bowing out — leaving the Patriots as the lone contender for his services yet again.
And instead of it feeling like there are a slew of teams vying for Brown’s services, this feels more like Philadelphia scraping the bottom of the barrel to find someone else to drive his price back up.
If it’s New England or bust, the Patriots will not be trading fair-market value for the receiver — and Roseman knows it.
But what is “fair” for Brown? Because a first- and second-round pick certainly isn’t it. Others around the league have suggested terms similar to those of his former Ole Miss teammate, D.K. Metcalf, who was dealt from the Seattle Seahawks to the Pittsburgh Steelers last offseason for a second-round pick and late-round pick swap.
Brown is certainly more accomplished at this point in his professional career, but how much does that realistically drive his market up if there’s only one team in the running?
As the days pass by, we’re only getting closer to an inevitable move off Brown for the Eagles. This weekend, they signed Dallas Goedert to a contract extension — just before they were smacked with a dead cap hit of $20 million from his deal last year. Without that on the books, Philadelphia has the cap flexibility to move on from Brown at any point — but “they’re in no rush.”
All of the reporting by network figureheads serves as posturing by both teams as they look to find common ground on a deal. They’re flip-flopping more than a fish out of water, but none of their swaying changes the facts that constitute the current situation:
Roseman wants his price, and the Patriots want Brown.
At this point, it seems like a foregone conclusion that Brown will end up in Foxboro prior to the start of the regular season. And if the Eagles are serious about being contenders without Brown this year, they’ll want assets that help their team win in 2026 — not 2027.
Goedert’s signing makes it financially feasible — and far more probable — that Brown is dealt prior to the 2026 NFL Draft. But even if New England is forced to wait until June 2 … Brown will be worth the wait.
–
Patriots Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Patriots. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.
–
Related Articles:
Check out the Patriots Roundtable Podcast!