New "Madden" Biopic A Flop Amongst Critics
Nov 18, 2026 7:36 PM
Updated Nov 18, 2026 10:02 PM

Now streaming on Amazon Prime, critics say "Madden" totally fails to capture the true essence of John Madden, the legendary Oakland Raiders' coach, sportscaster and video-game pitchman.

The reviews of the Las Vegas Raiders' performance on the field over the past seven weeks have not been great, but as far as reviews go, they could be a whole lot worse.

"Madden," the new biopic from acclaimed director-screenwriter-producer David O. Russell, which began streaming on Wednesday on Amazon Prime, has so far gotten reviews that make it sound like a failed fourth-down attempt from the one, a 105-yard Pick 6 and a "butt fumble" all rolled into one.

In more succinct words, "Madden" is a flop.

The film attempts - and apparently fails - to tell the story of beloved American icon John Madden, who was an ever-present force in the lives of most NFL fans for four decades, or from when he began coaching the Oakland Raiders in 1969 until he retired as a color analyst for NBC in 2009.

Related stories

In that time, he earned Hall of Fame recognition for his 10 seasons leading the Raiders, which included a 112-39-7 overall record and .731 winning percentage that remains the highest among NFL coaches with at least 100 games under their belts, along with the franchise's first Super Bowl championship following a 13-1 1976 season.

He followed that up with a 30-year broadcasting career that saw him set a new standard and style for game analysis, the first 15 years at CBS before he joined Fox for its first season broadcasting NFL games in 1994. After leaving Fox in 2002, he closed his career with four seasons doing "Monday Night Football" with ABC and four more on NBC for "Sunday Night Football."

As if that wasn't enough, Madden further left his mark on the game in 1988 when he lent his name, voice and creative input to the "John Madden Football" series of video games. To this day, the release date of the new season's version of "Madden Football" is circled on the calendars of gamers around the world.

With such a sterling resume and continuing cultural reach, Madden, who passed away on Dec. 28, 2021, makes an obviously intriguing subject for a biopic.

Unfortunately, the effort put forth by Russell appears to not come close to capturing the true essence of Madden the man, which may not be surprising considering some of the negative reactions to the movie's trailer when it was released in late September.

The main problem appears to be the most obvious one: the choice of Nicolas Cage to play Madden. While Cage's overall career has been of Hollywood's most notable over the past 40 years, and he does have a Best Actor Academy Award (for "Leaving Las Vegas" in 1995) on his mantle, his more recent performances have generally devolved into blustery overacting.

Cage's tone-deaf and clunky portrayal of Madden overshadows some allegedly great work by Christian Bale as bombastic Raiders' owner Al Davis, while Joel Murray is said to be just OK as Madden's CBS broadcasting sidekick Pat Summerall. Kathryn Hahn rounds out the film's leads as Madden's wife, Virginia.

But how bad is the movie, really?

Well, 14 of the 16 reviews to date on movie-review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes give the film a "splat," which means 87% of the reviewers disliked the the film with only 13% saying it is "certified fresh."

Any coach that goes 2-14 during the NFL season would be in line to be fired and it appears that based on the reviews "Madden" has received so far, it will soon be handed the proverbial "pink slip" and fade quietly into ignominy.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy