Nov 18, 2026 2:07 AM
As New Orleans reels from a sixth loss, analyst Ben Solak questions if the quarterback’s lack of aggression and limited ceiling will force a mid-season roster overhaul.
The New Orleans Saints (3-6) are searching for answers after a crushing 20-17 defeat to the Carolina Panthers (4-5). Carolina, who wrested sole possession of first place from the Saints, won the game on a last second field goal after a costly New Orleans penalty.
Somebody had to be first place in the division. Unfortunately, after five second chances the Saints suffered their sixth loss of the season through nine games. Some are looking at quarterback Tyler Shough as a potential cause of their struggles.
ESPN NFL analyst Ben Solak critiqued Shough's performance with several instances where Shough did not deliver when the Saints needed him. Here's what he had to say about the Saints needing a new quarterback for the 2027 season.
"If Shough cannot connect on deep balls and does not attack the intermediate area of the field, he cannot create the chunk gains necessary to hold down a starting quarterback job in the league. There is a mitigating concern here -- the Saints' running game has been among the league's worst since Shough took over the reins, and without that running game, Shough has to dink-and-dunk more often to keep his offense on schedule. But C.J. Stroud has a running game as ineffective as Shough's and is leading the league in air yards per attempt this year. It isn't enough to say "the running game is bad, the passing game will open up when it improves." Shough is a ceiling on this passing attack as much as the handoff game is.
Related stories
Shough will likely get a longer grace period than Penix might, seeing as he's only a second-year pro, but he is 27 and it's hard to imagine him improving much at this age. Of all the things difficult to teach a quarterback, aggression is perhaps the most challenging. Unless I see Shough decide to push the ball into tighter windows down the stretch of 2026, I'll wonder just how committed the Saints are to a second-round pick -- remember, he doesn't have a first-round pedigree! -- as the unquestioned starter."
Two years in, it's hard to say that Shough has been so bad that New Orleans would move in a different direction. The quarterback nearly secured NFL Rookie of the Year honors last year without much of a supporting cast.
Until Shough is complimented by a quality offensive line, competent running game and reliable defense, perhaps none of which the Saints have had for three consecutive games, we can't really judge what Shough brings the team.
We'll keep an eye on if he can bounce back against the Chicago Bears.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


