Nov 17, 2026 9:38 PM

It's too early to consider a new QB in 2027.

Patience is something that is rare in the NFL. Fans, media members, and even front offices can sometimes forget that development can take time. It's understandable that a decision has to be made when it's been over a year, but inexperienced players need time to develop.

This is where we start the Tyler Shough conversation. Sunday’s loss to the Carolina Panthers was Shough’s worst performance of his young career. He missed wide-open players consistently, couldn't look downfield, and ran out of clean pockets. These are mistakes that we didn't really see him make last season, but we are seeing that over these past few weeks, and instead of taking that step forward, it seems like Shough has regressed a bit. 

Of course, just like what has happened with CJ Stroud and even Drake Maye at the start of the season, many are jumping the gun, saying that the New Orleans Saints should consider a QB this offseason. Clearly, you can see my opinion on the topic. 

This season, Shough has been up and down, but he has had to play like a hero on offense nearly every single game. For any QB, this can become too much, but it's even worse for an inexperienced QB like Shough. Then, add the Saints' lack of run game, the fact that Shough is playing with a broken hand, and the offensive line’s pass-blocking woes. It's always easy to make excuses for a QB, and at some point, they do run out, but as of now, it's hard to blame Shough for feeling pressure even when the pocket is pretty clean. That also causes him to check the ball down quicker because he now thinks the pocket will close fast. 

Related stories

Kellen Moore can be credited with developing Shough last season because it was night and day when comparing his preseason play to what he did as a starter. It is arguably the one reason why firing Moore midseason may do some damage to Shough, but looking at recent weeks, Moore’s lack of a running game and the help given to the offensive line are bad for Shough. 

As of now, Shough isn't the long-term starter, and it's good that a new staff would consider options, but Shough has played like a top-15 QB at times, and that's a major selling point for head-coaching candidates. We will need to see what he can do in another offense before making any declarations about his future in New Orleans.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy