Powered by Roundtable
Saints Rookie Roundup: Post-Win vs Panthers cover image
AJCatuogno@RoundtableIO profile imagefeatured creator badge
AJ Catuogno
Nov 15, 2025
Partner

Shough makes history, Banks anchors the line, and Riley ignites the defense. New Orleans rookies are building a winning foundation.

Saints' Rookie Roundup: Week 11

For the first time all season, the Saints looked like a team putting all the pieces together.

New Orleans' 17–7 win over Carolina wasn’t just a sigh of relief, but a statement that this rebuild might actually have some real foundation to it.

And that foundation is being built on... by the rookies.

Rising: Tyler Shough

The biggest story of last week, Week 10, came under center. Quarterback Tyler Shough continues to make history in black and gold. 

Per WDSU, Shough became the first Saints rookie quarterback to win a game since 1981 and set a new franchise rookie passing record in the process.

He showed poise, leadership, and control, which is the kind of presence you can build around. And even with growing pains, Shough has been showing the kind of poise that makes coaches and fans believe this rebuild is on the right track.

Shough still has plenty to clean up, such as quicker decision-making under pressure and ball placement on deep routes, but the difference between this week and his earlier starts was undeniable.

For fans still clinging to the “lose for draft picks” mindset, Shough is proof that winning and developing can happen at the same time.

He’s not just learning. He’s leading.

Rising: Kelvin Banks Jr. 

Every good quarterback needs protection, and Kelvin Banks Jr. has delivered exactly that.

Banks has settled in as the Saints’ starting left tackle, showing rare composure for a rookie lineman. His combination of quick feet and physical strength has allowed him to anchor long-time pass rushers and an offensive line that looked shaky early in the year.

Banks' improvement week by week isn't difficult to see with fewer pressures allowed, better communication, and more confidence in run blocking. He’s not just holding his own, he’s establishing himself as a cornerstone for years to come.

In a league where left tackle stability is gold, Banks is already playing like someone who understands the assignment, mature beyond his peers on the field.

Rising: Quincy Riley

Quincy Riley might be the biggest pleasant surprise from this rookie class.

The fourth-round cornerback has become a spark for the Saints' defense with his instincts and playmaking ability. Riley’s quick reaction time has turned him into a turnover threat every week, and whether that's reading routes or breaking up passes, he has given the Saints something they’ve lacked. His timing and ball skills almost bring a flash of that old “Dome Patrol” energy back to the secondary.

Riley is still learning the jysts and details of zone coverage and tackling technique, but his progress is clear. When the ball’s in the air, Riley believes it’s his. And that mindset is contagious.

Rookie Watch: Danny Stutsman 

Danny Stutsman has quietly become one of the Saints’ most active defenders.

The rookie linebacker has shown incredible range, chasing plays sideline to sideline and cleaning up tackles in space. What stands out the most about Stutsman however, is his effort. He’s constantly around the football, showing the type of motor that can wear down an offense. Diagnosing plays quicker and reacting faster each week, his instincts have started catching up with his athleticism as well.

Stutsman brings toughness and heart to a defense that needed both. If he continues trending upward, he could anchor the middle of this defense for a long time.

Rebuild Taking Shape

This week, there are no “falling” rookies, and that alone says a lot.

The Saints’ win over Carolina wasn’t about one player carrying the load, but about everyone stepping up together.

Every rookie mentioned played a part, and that’s the kind of balanced progress a rebuilding team wants to see.

After weeks of inconsistency, the Saints finally looked like a group finding its identity. Tyler Shough continues to grow into the role of franchise quarterback. Kelvin Banks is turning into the steady presence the offensive line desperately needed. Quincy Riley keeps bringing energy and confidence to the defense, while Danny Stutsman’s intensity sets the tone for the front seven.

This is real development.

The Saints are seeing their draft investments pay off, and the future is starting to come into focus. With a young core that’s buying in and improving every week, New Orleans is building something worth watching. 

2