Nov 18, 2026 9:59 AM
The independent review panel clarifies why Cole Palmer was denied a crucial spot-kick before a controversial foul at the other end condemned the Blues to defeat.
The Premier League Key Match Incident Panel (KMI) has given its written explanation after Chelsea were denied a penalty in their 1-0 defeat away to Sunderland on November 8.
With the match goalless at the time of the incident, Cole Palmer was tripped on the edge of the penalty area. However, following a VAR review, referee Jarred Gillett decided to allow play to continue.
Moments later, Brian Brobbey was awarded a spot-kick after a tussle with Chelsea defender Levi Colwill. Following a booking for the incident, Xabi Alonso subsequently substituted the 23-year-old at half-time.
Enzo Le Fee's resulting penalty was enough to separate the two sides on the afternoon, a result that left the Blues fifth in the Premier League table heading into the international break.
Related stories
Following the incident, the KMI have revealed their reasoning behind both penalty claims that took place at the Stadium of Light.
The KMI consists of five independent members: three former players or coaches, one representative from the league and another from the referees' organisation, Pro Ref.
Despite Palmer believing he was fouled inside the penalty area, the panel unanimously agreed, by a margin of 4-1, that the Englishman had been fouled and a free-kick should have been awarded. However, they believed the contact took place outside the area. One panellist believed the 24-year-old should have been awarded a penalty.
The panel also believed VAR was correct not to intervene, as the contact took place outside the box. Once again, the panel agreed by a margin of 4-1.
In addition to the Blues' penalty claim, controversy surrounded the awarding of the home side's spot-kick. The KMI panel once again unanimously agreed that the Australian official had made the correct call and that VAR was also correct not to intervene. The panel agreed by a margin of 5-0.
The panel stated that there was “upper-body holding” from both Colwill and Brobbey as they progressed into the penalty area, before a “careless trip” by the 23-year-old defender.
Recently, the panel deemed that Palmer's altercation with Mateus Fernandes in the 2-0 defeat against Tottenham last month should have resulted in a straight red card for violent conduct. The midfielder escaped a straight red on the field but was later dismissed following a second bookable offence involving former teammate Conor Gallagher.
Chelsea host Leeds United at Stamford Bridge on Saturday afternoon as the Premier League returns following the final international break of 2026. The west London side will be looking to repeat the result of their League Cup tie in September, when the Blues won 6-3.
Michael Oliver will officiate the match with Michael Salisbury operating VAR. Oliver refereed the 4-3 victory for Alonso's side over Brighton back in August.
5
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


