Nov 18, 2026 7:00 AM
Everton have a decision to make on Tom King, Braiden Graham, Charly Alcaraz, and Michael Keane heading towards next summer.
Before the conclusion of the summer transfer window, Everton had a large number of players who were set to be out of contract in the summer of 2027.
Dwight McNeil, Beto, Tim Iroegbunam, and Nathan Patterson were among those, but all four were sold just a few months ago.
Everton had a decision to make on all four: sell them while they can, offer them a new deal, or let them leave for nothing.
In reality, Everton made the right decision on all four. The only arguable one is Iroegbunam. He's the player with the most potential and a new deal was another option, but Everton opted to cash in.
Related stories
The Toffees now have decisions to make on four more players, but it could be too late to sell them for decent fees.
Charly Alcaraz
Perhaps the most high-profile of the four, Charly Alcaraz.
In spells, Alcaraz has shown that he's a player capable of playing at Premier League level, but David Moyes doesn't seem to fancy him too much. He's also competing with one of Moyes' favourites, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, so it's always going to be tricky for him to receive regular minutes.
Losing him for free wouldn't make a lot of sense if we're honest. He's a player that does have resale value at the age of 23, so he should be offered a new contract, even if it's just to sell him in the near future.
Michael Keane
Could it finally be time we part ways with Michael Keane? He's going to be 34 by the time next summer comes around, and he's never going to be more than third-choice.
In reality, he could be fourth-choice, and it wouldn't be a surprise if Everton signed a new centre-back next summer due to the age of James Tarkowski.
With only four players out of contract, you can afford to lose someone like Keane, especially when the four players aren't guaranteed starters anyway.
It could be time to say goodbye to Keane.
Braiden Graham
At the age of 19, it wouldn't make sense to lose Braiden Graham for nothing.
You don't necessarily need to offer him a long-term, five-year contract, but at least tie him down for a few more years to see how he develops.
He's one of the most highly rated players in the academy, so losing him for nothing before he's even had a loan spell doesn't make sense.
Tie Graham down to a new contract.
Tom King
Tom King is still only 31 years old, and you'd imagine Mark Travers might be looking to move for first-team football next summer.
King appears to be a good person to have around the place, especially as he's someone who knows his position as third-choice.
Keeping King allows us to cash-in on Travers and only have to deal with signing one goalkeeper, rather than two.
He's likely on small wages, so a short-term deal would make sense.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy



