The prospect of Trent Alexander-Arnold returning to Liverpool might sound appealing on paper, but questions surrounding his fitness, defensive reliability and future at Real Madrid have cast doubt over whether such a move would make sense.

As speculation continues over the former Liverpool player's situation in Spain, journalist David Lynch has questioned whether Liverpool would have any interest in re-signing the 28-year-old, highlighting several reasons why a reunion might not be the right decision for Andoni Iraola’s side.

Lynch pointed to Alexander-Arnold’s injury problems, potential salary demands and uncertainty surrounding his long-term future as significant obstacles. He also suggested Liverpool would need to consider the defensive compromises that can accompany the right-back’s attacking style.

There is little doubt that Alexander-Arnold’s creative qualities remain exceptional. During his final Premier League campaign with Liverpool in 2024/25, he registered three goals and six assists in 25 league appearances, helping the club secure the title. 

However, his transition to Spanish football has proved more challenging than many anticipated. According to Opta Analyst, Alexander-Arnold made 21 La Liga appearances during the 2025/26 campaign, recording four assists without scoring. His opportunities have remained limited this season, with five league appearances, 265 minutes played and one assist recorded in the latest available figures. 

Those numbers underline the difficulty he has faced in establishing himself as a regular starter at the Bernabéu.

Alexander-Arnold’s passing range, crossing ability and delivery from set-pieces could undoubtedly offer Liverpool an attacking dimension. Nevertheless, any potential return would need to be assessed against the club’s existing options and wider squad-building priorities.

His defensive positioning has frequently attracted scrutiny, particularly when opponents exploit the space left behind during forward runs. Combined with his recent fitness concerns and the possibility of significant wage demands, those factors could make a deal difficult to justify.

Recent reporting has also highlighted competition for his place at Real Madrid, further fuelling questions about his future. However, speculation about a possible exit does not establish that Liverpool are pursuing him.

For now, a return to Anfield remains hypothetical rather than a confirmed transfer target.

Alexander-Arnold’s Liverpool legacy is undeniable, but nostalgia alone cannot determine recruitment decisions. If Liverpool were to consider bringing him home, they would need to be convinced that his creative brilliance outweighs the risks.

The question is no longer simply whether Trent could return to Liverpool. It is whether bringing him back would genuinely make the team stronger.

Would you like to see Trent Alexander-Arnold back at Liverpool? Leave your thoughts and comments below.