Nov 8, 2026 5:36 PM
Updated Nov 8, 2026 6:42 PM
Old Trafford witnessed a chaotic four-goal comeback as Patrick Dorgu’s last-gasp header rescued a point, masking defensive calamities and a disastrous afternoon for United’s struggling backline.
Michael Carrick made two changes to his Manchester United side that made an impressive comeback against Roma in the Champions League last week, with Noussair Mazraoui and Youri Tielemans replacing Ayden Heaven and the injured Carlos Baleba, respectively, in a crucial Premier League clash, as United needed a win to lift themselves out of the relegation zone, having not won in the league since August.
It was a terrible start to proceedings as the home side found themselves 2-0 down within four minutes, the quickest they have ever gone two goals down in the Premier League, but quickly turned things around, as Bruno Fernandes slotted home from the penalty spot in the 16th minute, and United's dominance only grew as they continued to threaten the Villa goal, and they finally regained parity just before the half-time break when Youri Tielemans scored his first United goal.
The feeling of hope at Old Trafford was quickly extinguished in the second half as Aston Villa were again quick out of the blocks, with Dalot giving away a penalty shortly after the second half began, before Leon Goretzka scored following calamitous defending on an Aston Villa free-kick.
United offered little when chasing the game, with Mason Mount hitting the post, but two United substitutes contributed to the home side's third, as Patrick Dorgu found Joshua Zirkzee with a great pass after a solo run, allowing the Dutch forward to finish in the 92nd minute.
That rejuvenated the side with the belief they could snatch an equaliser, and Dorgu again turned from provider to scorer, capping off a frantic end to the second half with a dramatic last-minute goal to give Carrick's side an unlikely point.
United player ratings vs Aston Villa
Senne Lammens - 3/10
While he was decent after Aston Villa went up 2- 0, he had an awful start to the game, as he should have done much better on Alysson's opening goal and made a poor parry from the free-kick, allowing Jackson to double the visitors' lead. Unfortunately, it was one of his worst displays in a United shirt.
Noussair Mazraoui - 3/10
Struggled in the early stages of the half, and found it hard to deal with the threat from Johan Manzambi down his side. While he's not known for his attacking threat, he did well to assist United's equaliser on the stroke of half-time. Struggled to deal with Senny Mayulu when he came on in the second half. Overall, a torrid evening for both of United's full-backs
Leny Yoro - 3/10
A weak, headed clearance from Aston Villa's free-kick let the hosts grab their second of the game, but it grew into the first half. Disastrous start to the second half, heading the ball onto his own bar when he didn't need to, which led to Villa's fourth. Calamitous error from the young centre-back.
Harry Maguire - 4/10
Not at fault for either of United's conceded goals, he handled threats against him reasonably well. Yoro often pushed further forward, leaving Maguire to marshal the back line. Passing was a bit off at times, and he was substituted at half-time
Diogo Dalot - 1/10
Dalot's disastrous defensive performance against Roma continued into the Aston Villa fixture. He gave Alysson too much space on his side, allowing him to score the visitors' opener, before giving away a penalty in the first minute of the second half. One of the loudest cheers of the game came when the Portugal international was substituted just after the hour mark.
Youri Tielemans 7/10
One of his best performances in a United shirt against his former side, marshalling the midfield well alongside Mainoo. Offered a lot going forward and was rewarded by scoring the equaliser in the 44th minute. It was a bit of a surprise to see him substituted 15 minutes into the second half.
Kobbie Mainoo 7/10
After returning to Carrick's starting lineup from a brief injury, Kobbie Mainoo picked up where he left off, forming a strong midfield partnership with Tielemans.
Amad 5/10
It's so frustrating to watch Amad play, because he has been a huge threat down the right flank so far for United, and can dribble past defenders for fun, but his finishing is just not good enough, and with the chances he had in the first half, he should have been on the score sheet.
Bruno Fernandes 6/10
Linked up well with Matheus Cunha, Mainoo, and Tielemans to galvanise United's forward threat after going two-nil down and, as expected, dispatched his penalty. Saw a deflected effort go agonisingly wide of the post in the first half. He didn't offer much in the second half as United chased two goals, but when it mattered most, he whipped in a great corner in the dying moments to assist Patrick Dorgu's last-minute equaliser.
Matheus Cunha - 6/10
After a stellar Champions League performance, Matheus Cunha once again gave United a lifeline against Aston Villa, earning a penalty in the 15th minute and nearly scoring right after United got back into the game, but Suzuki's great save denied the Brazilian. Worked hard off the ball, as the United faithful have come to expect.
Bryan Mbeumo - 4/10
Bryan Mbeumo was a complete passenger in the first half, with little impact. Had a decent chance in the second half but couldn't convert and was perhaps lucky to be on the pitch for 82 minutes before being replaced by Joshua Zirkzee.
Substitutes
Ayden Heaven - 4/10
Shea Lacey - 6/10
Patrick Dorgu - 8/10
In his first club appearance since the end of September, Dorgu put in a remarkable 30-minute cameo, assisting Zirkzee for what many thought was a consolation goal before scoring a dramatic late equaliser from a Bruno Fernandes corner to earn his side a point.
Mason Mount - 5/10
Joshua Zirkzee - 6/10
2
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


