Nov 18, 2026 1:15 PM
As Mauricio Pochettino inherits a leaky defense at Old Trafford, club legend Gary Neville identifies the essential veterans and liability risks the Argentine must address immediately.
Mauricio Pochettino has already admitted he knows he will face a "very intense" environment and challenge upon taking over as Manchester United's new head coach.
The former Chelsea and Tottenham Hotspur head coach has replaced Michael Carrick as the club's first-team boss after the Reds have won just one of their opening ten Premier League fixtures.
Pochettino's US squad defeated Haiti 8-0 over two legs during the last international break, and his departure was sorely felt by the USMNT, although United, with his £7.4 million release clause, had to let him go and return to England.
The Argentinian's coaching staff have already been working at Carrington since the weekend, with Pochettino set to get his first taste of life at United on Wednesday afternoon as he takes training ahead of a huge Sunday afternoon clash against Liverpool.
Related stories
Neville outlines what to do with 19 United stars
Pochettino's immediate task at United is to improve the club's form by stopping the defence from leaking so many goals. The side have scored only one fewer league goal than table-toppers Arsenal, but have conceded the most in Europe across all competitions (30).
In the January transfer window, it's been claimed that United are prepared to back their new boss and provide funds to strengthen the squad's defense, with the club linked to a possible move for Fulham centre-back Calvin Bassey.
But, plans for a squad overhaul in the summer are already beginning to take shape, and speaking on the Stick to United podcast, former club captain and Gary Neville outlined what he feels Pochettino should do with 19 of his new first-team players.
Starting with the defence, Neville immediately stated he feels Luke Shaw, whose contract expires in the summer, will be kept due to their time together at Southampton, while Harry Maguire could be retained as a 'soldier' in the back line.
“Out of the defenders, he’ll keep Shaw because he knows him, and he’ll probably get the best out of him," Neville started. "The problem with Luke is injuries, and you’ll have to manage him.
“He’ll keep Maguire because he’ll trust him and think he’s basically a soldier, someone who can do a job for him."
Neville also stated he feels Pochettino will also want to work with young centre-back Leny Yoro, who has shown periods of high potential but inconsistent form across the last 18 months, while Ayden Heaven may be loaned out.
“He’ll keep Yoro because he’ll think there’s something to work with. Heaven, I’d loan him out and get some experience in the Championship. He’s nowhere near it; it’s unfair to put him in the situation he’s in."
As for the midfield, Mason Mount is the player Neville pinpointed as a must-leave, while Kobbie Mainoo, Youri Tielemans, and club captain Bruno Fernandes should be kept. Andrey Santos and Carlos Baleba, two summer signings, may also interest Pochettino.
“I’d keep Bruno [Fernandes], I’d keep Kobbie [Mainoo], I’d keep [Youri] Tielemans, [Mason] Mount would have to go," he continued.
“[Andrey] Santos - Mauricio may like him because he’s young, quite mobile, he’s aggressive, he might get something out of him. Him and [Carlos] Baleba will be in that middle bit. Mount’s the one that goes definitely, in that midfield section.”
Heading toward the attack, of which United have invested over £200 million in the last few years, Joshua Zirkzee and Marcus Rashford are the names who Neville feels will be on the chopping block come the end of the 2026/27 campaign, alongside Manuel Ugarte.
“Zirkzee definitely to go, I would think,” he restarted. “I think Marcus 100 per cent to go because of the fact he’s on massive money and that story has been well told.
“They can’t afford to pay him that money, he’s in that section where you have to get rid of that wage at the earliest opportunity.
“He’ll work with Amad, he’ll work with [Bryan] Mbeumo, he’ll work with [Matheus] Cunha and he’ll work with [Benjamin] Sesko and think, ‘okay, I’ll make you into a centre-forward’.
“He’ll use [Patrick] Dorgu in the short term but he’ll be one who will go in the next couple of years. Ugarte will go, 100 per cent.”
A defencive overhaul needed
According to reports dating back several years, United had always earmarked the 2027 summer transfer window as the window where the club will invest heavily in defence, bringing in major reinvofrcemnts.
Speaking further, Neville explained that a whole overhaul must happen with several of the club's experienced defenders, like Lisandro Martinez and Matthijs de Ligt, needing to make way for fresh talent.
“If you look through it now, I’d say Martinez would go, De Ligt would go, [Noussair] Mazraoui would go, Mount would go, first wave next summer. Rashford ,if you can, and Zirkzee.
“And then the year after you’d be looking at Shaw, Maguire, [Diogo] Dalot, Bruno, that’s your second wave and maybe then you’ve made your mind up on Baleba and Santos.
“But the earliest Mauricio Pochettino can unravel this squad is two seasons if he does well. It could take three to get this squad unravelled.”
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


