Does Josh Naylor Need to Change His Approach For 2027?
Sep 9, 2026 5:00 PM
Updated Sep 9, 2026 5:36 PM

The Seattle Mariners' big-ticket free agent acquisition has slumped offensively this year, but what can be done about it?

On Tuesday night, the Seattle Mariners lost to the Texas Rangers 10-5 at T-Mobile Park, essentially ending their season.

Even though the playoff hopes were extremely limited heading into Tuesday, the M's are now 67-78 and seven games back of the Houston Astros with 17 games to play. Mathematically, it's possible, but realistically, it's not. 

As a result, we're all left wondering what happened during this ill-fated 2026 season, and how it can get better for 2027.

Once the offseason officially hits, there will be plenty of time to talk about managers, the front office, ownership, the budget, possible roster additions, a lockout, and how the Mariners look in relation to the rest of the American League West.

Related stories

However, we've already started asking some questions, like if the M's can truly count on their starting rotation moving forward, and there's another that I want to ask as well.

What's happened to Josh Naylor this season? And does he need to change something in 2027?

It's actually a fascinating case study, so let's dive in.

Seattle Mariners first baseman Josh Naylor (12) hits a single against the Athletics during the fourth inning at T-Mobile Park. Steven Bisig-Imagn ImagesSeattle Mariners first baseman Josh Naylor (12) hits a single against the Athletics during the fourth inning at T-Mobile Park. Steven Bisig-Imagn Images

About Naylor

Now 29 years old, Naylor is an eight-year veteran of the San Diego Padres, Cleveland Guardians, Arizona Diamondbacks and Mariners.

He's hitting .267 this season, which is actually a decent batting average in today's hitting-suppressed game, but it's the other numbers that have cratered. He has just 10 home runs, which would be his lowest in any season in which he's played at least 70 games (17 in 2023). He has just 49 RBIs, which would be his lowest since 2022 (79), when he played only 122 games. 

His slugging percentage is .362, well below his career average of .433, and his OPS is .686, well below his career average of .762.

So what's going on?

The one thing that we know about Naylor is that he's excellent at making contact, and as a result, he doesn't strike out much at all.

He's in the 92nd percentile of strikeout rate and in the 84th percentile of whiff rate. He simply doesn't swing and miss very often, and he doesn't strike out, which is typically a good thing.

So what's the problem? 

Well, Naylor has historically had a rather aggressive approach at the plate, and when you pair that with his ability to make contact, he's gotten himself out quite a lot this season.

It was evident on Tuesday: With the M's trailing 4-0, Naylor was up with two runners on and one out. He chased two splitters, fouling them off, before waving at a third way out of the zone. He thinks he can hit everything, so he swings at everything. He was bailed out when Laz Montes hit a mammoth home run to make it 4-3, but from Naylor's perspective, the at-bat was poor.

Ironically enough, it seems as if Naylor's ability to make consistent contact has actually contributed to his poor season. Take a look at the numbers, per Baseball Savant.

Naylor has a 38 percent chase rate, which is in the 10th percentile, but he also makes contact on 71.5 percent of pitches he chases on.

AKA: He swings at bad pitches, but also hits them. It's really hard to do consistent damage when you are actually hitting bad pitches. You would often be better served to miss the bad pitches, see more pitches, and hope one of the following pitches is a mistake that you can do damage on.

What's interesting about the whole thing

Naylor's approach is really the same as it's always been. Almost nothing has changed.

1) He swings at 71.2 percent of pitches in the strike zone for his career. This year, he's at 69.1. So, a slight drop, but not much.

2) He's making contact in the strike zone more than he has before, which should be a good thing. He makes contact on 90 percent of pitches in the zone. Last year, he was at 86.9 percent.

3) The chase rate of 38 percent is high, but his career average is 35.1, also high. Last season, Naylor had a great year with a chase rate of 37.1 percent. In 2023, his chase rate was even higher, and he hit .308 with 97 RBIs. So, he has had success despite this super-aggressive approach.

4) Naylor is swinging at the first pitch a ton (40.3 percent), but it's actually significantly lower than last season (44.1) AND 2023 (46.4). It's barely higher than 2024 when he had 31 homers and 108 RBIs.

So really, the under-the-hood metrics are almost all the same. The biggest difference? It's that "chase contact percentage," of 71.5 percent, which is the highest of his career by at least two percentage points, and more than five percentage points higher than his career norm.

One other thing to consider...

It's been evident, at various times, that Naylor has been hampered by a sore wrist. How much is this alone causing problems? We will only find out in the offseason, if even then. But there's certainly a chance that everything could stay the same in 2027, but overall numbers will improve with better health.

Even with better health, it would still be advisable that he work on swinging at better pitches more consistently. 

The main conclusion

Look, Naylor has had had MASSIVE seasons before, deploying this exact same approach. I think it would be unfair for me to say that he HAS to change his approach given the success he's had.

That said, I do firmly believe that there should be an adjustment on his end. I think the goal should always be to swing at more pure strikes, especially early in the count. If you are chasing early in counts, you are doing the pitcher a favor, and it's something that Naylor has done far too often this season. When you couple that with the wrist issue, it's clearly been a net-negative.

If Naylor can get ahead in more counts, and lay off the pitches he's been swinging at early, then he can bring the pitcher back into the strike zone, which gives him the chance to do more damage, which we know he's capable of doing.

Of note

The latest edition of the 'Refuse to Lose Territory' podcast is out, talking about the M's rotation woes, if Lazaro Montes and Michael Arroyo should play every day now, and if the M's really have a chance at the playoffs.

You can listen here, or you can watch in the YouTube player below.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy