Are the Marlins' Current Owners the Worst in Baseball?
Nov 11, 2026 4:59 AM

With the worst attendance in the league and low payroll, is Bruce Sherman MLB's worst overall owner?

For years, Miami Marlins fans have chewed on a question that goes beyond pitching rotations, offensive stats, or farm system prospects: Who is running things in the front office? Do Bruce Sherman and his ownership group truly represent the worst management team in Major League Baseball?

While it is tough to grant them that title, especially given the occasional bright spot on the diamond, a compelling case could be made if you examine the franchise's history of financial cutbacks, stagnant attendance figures, and endless rebuilds.

In 2017, Sherman partnered with Derek Jeter to buy the Marlins from Jeffrey Loria for roughly $1.2 billion. Intended to mark a fresh chapter for a franchise long burdened by questionable leadership, the ownership change has unfortunately fallen short of bringing the meaningful transformation fans hoped to see.

Loria's tenure was particularly controversial. He purchased the franchise in 2002 for approximately $158 million, with Major League Baseball providing financial assistance to complete the transaction. Fifteen years later, he sold it for $1.2 billion, despite years of criticism surrounding payroll decisions, attendance, and the team's commitment to competing.

Related stories

Sherman inherited that reputation, but his partnership with Jeter eventually encountered its own problems.

In February 2022, Jeter walked away from the organization, surrendering his 4% ownership stake. His explanation was particularly revealing. Jeter said the franchise's future vision was different from the one he had originally agreed to lead. That departure raised questions about the relationship between baseball operations and ownership, particularly regarding the financial commitment necessary to build a contender.

Sherman insisted the organization had money to spend. However, the subsequent years haven't consistently demonstrated an appetite for substantial investment in the major-league roster.

Financing the Fish

According to Forbes' 2026 valuation figures, the Marlins are worth approximately $1.5 billion, ranking 30th among MLB franchises. Forbes also estimated $320 million in revenue and $53 million in operating income, with player expenses listed at $99 million. Those financial figures are based on the 2025 season.

Meanwhile, Miami struggles to attract fans. The Marlins ranked last in National League attendance in 2026, averaging approximately 15,198 fans per game. Winning certainly influences attendance, but a franchise cannot expect its supporters to continually invest emotionally and financially without demonstrating a sustained commitment to winning.

Sherman reportedly sold a 15% stake in the franchise in 2026, generating approximately $232 million, with proceeds expected to help address team debt and strengthen its financial position. Whether that translates into greater spending on the roster remains to be seen.

Perhaps calling the Marlins' ownership the worst in baseball is premature. Other franchises have experienced similarly frustrating ownership situations, and Miami's recent progress complicates that argument.

The friends of the Fin would be better served with a multi-billionaire who is committed to winning and keeping the team securely in Miami. That's a perfect scenario, but it's also the dream of every Major League fan base out there.

But ownership isn't measured exclusively by franchise valuations or operating profits. It is measured by ambition, investment, accountability and the willingness to give supporters a team capable of competing.

Sherman has another opportunity to change the narrative; The Marlins appear closer to becoming a legitimate contender. The question is whether their owner will finally be willing to invest accordingly.

Otherwise, Miami could discover that changing the names in the owner's box doesn't necessarily change the story.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy