A bold lease signed in 1972 promised Detroit a domed future. Explore the ambitious plans and swift unraveling of a revolutionary stadium.
On this date in January 1972, the Detroit Tigers appeared to take a decisive step toward reshaping baseball — and downtown Detroit — by signing a lease to play in a proposed riverfront domed stadium.
At the time, city and county leaders framed the agreement as transformational. The Tigers committed as the primary tenant of a fully enclosed, climate-controlled facility that would rival the Houston Astrodome and position Detroit as a modern, forward-thinking sports city. The stadium was envisioned as a year-round economic engine, capable of hosting baseball, football, concerts, conventions, and postseason college games.
The financial framework underscored both the ambition and fragility of the plan. The Tigers were projected to pay $624,000 annually in rent by 1975, calculated as 10 percent of ticket revenue, with the average ticket price estimated at $3 and roughly 27,000 fans per game. Stadium officials projected $3.39 million in baseball-related revenue, while total annual operating costs were expected to reach $13 million.
Mayor Roman Gribbs, announcing the deal amid severe budget cuts and layoffs across the city, famously described the signing as turning “a day of gloom in Detroit into a very promising, joyous day.” Tigers owner John Fetzer, who already owned Tiger Stadium at Michigan and Trumbull, acknowledged the risks but framed the decision as a civic obligation — a belief that keeping the Tigers downtown could help stabilize and revive the city.
Yet even in January, one reality was openly acknowledged: baseball alone could not sustain the stadium.
Wayne County Stadium Authority chairman Thomas Adams made clear that the financial model depended on football dates and other large-scale events. The stadium needed roughly 136 event days per year, including 81 baseball games and up to 10 football games, to avoid operating at a loss. That placed immense pressure on convincing the Detroit Lions to abandon their commitment to a proposed stadium in Pontiac.
That pressure never paid off — and by June, the entire project unraveled.
In June 1972, the Michigan Supreme Court halted construction of the riverfront dome, ruling that the Wayne County Stadium Authority could not proceed under its existing financing plan. The court determined that public funds could not be used to build a stadium that primarily benefited a privately owned professional baseball team, freezing the bond sale that was intended to finance construction.
The ruling did not explicitly kill the project — but it required a new financial agreement between the Stadium Authority and the Tigers to justify the use of public money.
That renegotiation never occurred.
Fetzer made it clear that the Tigers would not reopen lease discussions, stating publicly that the organization was satisfied with the agreement it had already signed and had no interest in altering its terms. Without a revised deal, county officials had no legal pathway to move forward.
The contrast with Pontiac was stark. While Detroit’s plan became mired in legal and political uncertainty, Pontiac’s proposal moved ahead with fewer obstacles. By 1975, the Pontiac Silverdome opened as the Lions’ new home, cementing a regional shift that Detroit leaders had hoped to avoid.
For the Tigers, the outcome was definitive. The riverfront dome faded from possibility into memory, Tiger Stadium remained their home for another 27 seasons, and Detroit’s grand vision of a downtown, domed baseball future became one of the city’s most enduring “what-ifs.”
In hindsight, the story of 1972 is less about a stadium that failed and more about a moment when optimism collided with legal reality, revealing how close Detroit came to taking a dramatically different path.
Follow me on "X" @rogcastbaseball