The Tarik Skubal trade conversation has reached the point where the direction seems to change with every Tigers series.

This indecision's bugging me (Esta indecisión me molesta)

If you don't want me, set me free (Si no me quieres, líbrame)

Exactly whom I'm supposed to be (Dígame qué tengo ser)

Don't you know which clothes even fit me? (¿Sabes qué ropa me queda?)

Come on and let me know (Ahora me tienes que decir)

Should I cool it, or should I blow? (¿Me debo ir o quedarme?)

(The Clash: Should I stay or Should I Go Now, 1981)

When Detroit was losing throughout May, the national conversation moved toward Skubal being dealt. When the Tigers played better in June and surged around the All-Star break, the reporting shifted toward Scott Harris keeping him. After an 11-2 loss to the Cubs, another report emerged detailing the type of controllable starting pitcher Detroit would want as part of a trade package.

This is the part that has become tiring and annoying. 

There are legitimate baseball arguments for trading Skubal. There are also legitimate reasons to keep him. What has been frustrating is the constant presentation of speculation as if the Tigers have made a final decision, only for another report to appear a few days later suggesting the opposite.

Earlier this month, ESPN’s Jeff Passan and Kiley McDaniel placed Skubal’s chances of being traded at 85 percent. More recent reports have suggested Detroit is leaning toward keeping him. A prediction market moved the probability of a Skubal trade to 56 percent Wednesday, although that market had less than $100,000 in volume and should not be treated as reporting from the Tigers.

Meanwhile, the latest information from Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon indicates the Tigers would seek a controllable starting pitcher and additional prospects in a Skubal deal. The reported pitching possibilities include Emmet Sheehan, Logan Henderson, Ian Seymour, Andrew Painter, JR Ritchie, AJ Smith-Shawver, Will Warren and Ryan Weathers. That sounds less like Detroit actively shopping Skubal and more like Harris establishing the threshold another organization would have to clear.

The best argument for trading Skubal is asset management.

He is scheduled to reach free agency after the season. Unless the Tigers sign him to an extension, the return for keeping him through the year could eventually be reduced to qualifying-offer draft compensation.

Trading him now would allow Detroit to turn roughly two months of Skubal into several years of team control. If Harris could acquire a young major-league starter, another upper-level arm and an impact position player, the deal could help the Tigers address several roster problems at once.

It also would reduce the risk associated with trying to re-sign a pitcher who could receive one of the largest contracts in baseball history. Skubal is earning $32 million this season, and there has been little public indication that the sides are close to an extension.

The Scott Boras element has to be considered, although it is often simplified too much.

That does not mean Boras controls Skubal’s decision or that an extension is impossible. The player ultimately makes the decision. It does suggest the Tigers should expect Skubal to test his market unless they are prepared to make an offer that reflects his full open-market value.

The strongest argument against trading Skubal is the standings.

Following Tuesday’s loss to Chicago, the Tigers were 47-54 and five games behind the final American League wild-card position. That is hardly an ideal position, but it is also not the type of deficit that automatically ends a season with more than two months remaining.

If the Tigers believe they still have a reasonable chance to qualify for the postseason, removing Skubal would make that path significantly more difficult. He is the pitcher Detroit would want starting the first game of a postseason series. He also showed against the Angels on Saturday that he remains capable of controlling a game, throwing seven scoreless innings with nine strikeouts and no walks.

There is also no guarantee that a trade centered on prospects will work. Even highly regarded young players carry developmental and injury risk. The Tigers could trade an established ace, miss the postseason anyway and spend several seasons waiting to learn whether the return was sufficient. Harris can claim a small victory for Hao-Yu Lee and Matt Vierling but those are not complete stories yet. 

Detroit also would have the opportunity to pursue Skubal in free agency even after keeping him through the season. Boras clients reach the market frequently, but reaching free agency does not prevent the original team from retaining the player. The issue is whether ownership is willing to compete financially once every interested club can make an offer.

This is where Harris’ lack of public visibility has become part of the story.

Saying Harris has literally disappeared would be unfair. He is running the baseball operations department and is presumably working the phones as the deadline approaches. But he has largely removed himself from the public-facing portion of the Skubal conversation.

Harris’ most direct explanation came during the Winter Meetings, when he said he does not believe in labeling players as untouchable and cannot properly do his job without listening to trade possibilities. That is a reasonable front-office philosophy, but it has not provided much guidance during the latest stretch of rumors.

In Harris’ absence, every national report fills the information gap. One day Skubal is 85 percent likely to be traded. The next week, Detroit is leaning toward keeping him. Then the Tigers’ potential asking price becomes public. I get it, don't show your cards but does anyone really know?

Harris does not need to reveal private negotiations or declare Skubal unavailable. A measured public update on how the organization views its competitive position would provide some useful context. Instead, manager A.J. Hinch and Skubal have handled most of the questions while the person responsible for the decision has remained quiet.

The short answer is no.

Toledo has pitchers capable of providing major-league innings. Sawyer Gipson-Long has recorded 68 strikeouts over 69 2/3 innings, although he has a 4.78 ERA. Dylan File has made 17 starts with a 5.63 ERA. The active roster also includes Emanuel De Jesus and Troy Watson, (Both 40-man roster pitchers) while Ty Madden was recalled by Detroit yesterday and pitched out of the bullpen. 

That is functional depth, but there is no immediate replacement for Skubal’s production.

Erie offers more developmental interest. Andrew Sears has a 2.86 ERA in five Double-A starts, while Hayden Minton has posted a 2.29 ERA through five starts. Carlos Peña has 68 strikeouts and only nine walks in 61 1/3 innings, although he has allowed 13 home runs and really is a minor league arm, as he tops out at 92 MPH. Jackson Jobe is currently with Erie on a rehabilitation assignment. His role, to me, is yet to be determined, if the Tigers keep him, since they could throw him in the bullpen. 

The health situation complicates the Double-A picture. Jake Miller and Joe Miller are on the seven-day injured list,(Currently rehabbing at West Michigan),  Jaden Hamm is on the 60-day injured list, and Garrett Burhenn is listed as out for the full season.

That depth chart helps explain Detroit’s reported asking price. If Skubal is traded, Harris cannot build the return entirely around low-level prospects. He needs a starter who can step into the major-league rotation and remain under team control beyond 2026.

The Tigers do not have to trade Skubal simply because he is approaching free agency. They also should not keep him solely because trading a homegrown ace would be unpopular.

The decision should come down to an honest evaluation of the current roster. If Harris believes this team has a legitimate chance to reach October, keeping Skubal is defensible. If he believes the recent winning stretch has covered up a roster that remains several pieces short, then this is the final opportunity to turn Skubal into a significant package.

Until Harris makes that assessment clear through either his words or his actions, the rumor cycle will continue moving without providing much actual clarity, and we will get pounded with speculation until then.

Follow me on "X" @rogcastbaseball