Nov 20, 2026 1:33 AM
With a $5 million arbitration deadline looming, Detroit must weigh Zach McKinstry’s versatile defensive utility against his offensive struggles as rising prospects challenge for bench roles.
Max Anderson won a minor league Gold Glove at second base. Peyton Graham stole 66 bases for Double-A Erie. Both joined the Tigers’ 40-man roster Tuesday, giving A.J. Hinch two more infielders to look at in spring training. With a decision on Zach McKinstry’s contract due Friday, there’s one detail worth keeping in mind about the veteran utility man. The position he played most often in 2026 was in the outfield.
It was the first time since 2021 that McKinstry had spent more games at an outfield position than at any other spot, according to MLB.com’s breakdown of the Gold Glove finalists. That makes him an interesting test of how Detroit wants to build its bench. Hinch could send McKinstry out to replace a corner outfielder one night and write him into the infield the next afternoon. Matching that flexibility might take two players, and both would need enough at-bats to justify carrying them.
The price of that flexibility is going up. McKinstry made $4.2 million in 2026, and MLB Trade Rumors projects an arbitration salary around $5 million for 2027. Friday’s 5 p.m. Eastern deadline gives Detroit a choice. Tender him a contract and the sides can negotiate the salary over the winter. Let the deadline pass without an offer and McKinstry can talk to every club as a free agent.
His offensive line gives Detroit a reason to pause. McKinstry hit .199 with a .288 on-base percentage and four home runs in 129 games. He also got caught five times in eight stolen-base attempts. If Hinch needs a pinch-hitter to start a rally in the seventh inning, it’s difficult to make a case for McKinstry on those numbers. His strongest case comes an inning later, when a pinch-hitter has already come off the bench and somebody needs to take the field.
Related stories
Tuesday’s moves make that second job a little harder to fill internally. Detroit designated Matt Vierling and Trey Sweeney for assignment and traded Jace Jung to the Angels on Wednesday. Anderson gives the Tigers a credible option at second. Graham spent this season in Double-A. If the plan is to get either prospect regular work against Triple-A pitching, keeping him on a major league bench for a handful of starts a month comes with a development cost, too.
I’d tender McKinstry. The deciding factor for me is what it lets Detroit do with Anderson in April. If Anderson hits his way into everyday work, give him the at-bats. If he needs another month in Toledo, Hinch can still cover an infield start and a late change in the outfield with one name on his lineup card. At a projected $5 million, that’s the job I’d be paying McKinstry to do.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


