White Sox Free Agency Options for Backup Catcher
Nov 18, 2026 10:00 PM

With Joey Bart designated for assignment, the White Sox have a hole at backup catcher. Three veteran free agents stand out as potential fits behind Kyle Teel.

As the Chicago White Sox shuffled their 40-man roster to protect Rule 5-eligible prospects on Tuesday, catcher Joey Bart was designated for assignment.

Bart was acquired by the White Sox at the 2026 trade deadline in a deal that sent right-handed pitcher Duncan Davitt to the Atlanta Braves. He was brought in to reinforce a weak catching position, providing strong defense and a right-handed hitting alternative to Kyle Teel.

Unfortunately, Bart made it just three games into his White Sox tenure before suffering a broken hand on a hit-by-pitch and being shut down for the remainder of the season.

Early indications this offseason suggested that the White Sox could choose to bring Bart back. It was a real coin flip. With Bart projected to earn $2.9 million in arbitration, Chicago decided to go in a different direction.

Related stories

That leaves the backup catching role once again up in the air. The two top options for the White Sox at the moment are Edgar Quero and Drew Romo, both of whom struggled mightily at the MLB level in 2026 and led to Chicago's mad dash for help behind the plate late in the season.

Quero hit .203 with a .540 OPS and was worth -0.5 fWAR while being one of the worst defensive catchers in baseball. Quero ranked in the fifth percentile in blocks above average, was in the bottom 25% in framing and pop time, and was one of baseball's slowest runners.

While Romo was slightly better defensively, ranking around average or better in framing, pop time and caught stealing above average, he wasn't a particularly sharp blocker either. And his .144 batting average and .535 OPS made it impossible to justify regular playing time for him.

Needless to say, the White Sox shouldn't feel content with a tandem of Quero and Romo as their options at backup catcher. Now with Bart off the roster, what are the team's options in free agency?

What Should the White Sox Look for in a Backup Catcher?

For starters, I don't believe the White Sox are going to be in the market for a quality starting catcher.

While Carson Kelly and Tyler Stephenson are both talented players who would make the team better, they'll both land starting gigs somewhere and be paid like the starters they are. That's higher than the White Sox will be bidding.

What I'm looking for is a veteran right-handed hitting catcher. Someone who can hit lefties well and occasionally spell Teel in the starting lineup as a strategic complement. Knowing how much the White Sox value defense (they kept Romo on the roster over Quero in 2026 because he was a defensive upgrade), they'd also ideally be at least an average defender.

Looking at the free agent list, let's go through a process of elimination.

Reese McGuire bats left-handed, so he's out. Jonah Heim and Gary Sánchez are both defensive liabilities, which takes them out of the running.

I think it's safe to assume the White Sox aren't interested in reuniting with Jake Rogers after his brief stint with the team in 2026, and I'm not sure Luke Maile or Travis d'Arnaud are big leaguers anymore, given their age and recent performance.

Maile played in just 18 games with a .502 OPS in 2026. He'll be 36 years old on Opening Day. d'Arnaud had a .475 OPS and played in only 32 games last season. He'll be 38 on Opening Day. Both of them are out.

James McCann is an interesting reunion candidate, but he, too, is below average defensively. While the offensive upside is there, McCann has reverse splits and has struggled to hit left-handed pitching in three of the last four seasons. In 2026, he had a .878 OPS against right-handers and a .561 OPS against lefties. That's not the complement the White Sox are looking for. He's out.

That leaves us with just three names: Austin Hedges, Kyle Higashioka and Christian Vázquez.

Austin Hedges

Hedges is probably the one who makes the most sense to me.

He's known for his tremendous defense behind the plate, but took a step forward offensively in 2026 as well, posting a .702 OPS. Even if you get nothing from him at the plate, his defensive value would make up for it.

Hedges' game-calling ability, veteran experience and knowledge of the AL Central after spending five of the last six seasons in Cleveland would help both Teel and the White Sox pitching staff. If he's open to the idea of joining his former AL Central enemy, it's something the White Sox should consider.

Kyle Higashioka

Higashioka is a below-average defender, but that may be something the White Sox are willing to overlook for his experience and offensive upside.

He's had an OPS+ of 96 or higher in each of the last three seasons, and in 2026, he posted a .841 OPS against left-handed pitching. He'd be a comfortable backup option for the White Sox if they prioritize offense and lineup depth over a defensive specialist.

Christian Vázquez

Vázquez is hit or miss behind the plate. He was in the 11th percentile in blocks above average and doesn't have a great arm, but he's one of the best pitch framers in the game and has graded out as a well-above-average defender in every year of his big league career.

The offense has been fading, however, and Vázquez hasn't posted an OPS above .600 in at least four seasons, which ultimately makes him my third choice of this group.

White Sox Could Explore the Trade Market

We shouldn't rule out the trade market. The White Sox had plenty of interest in swinging a deal for one of the catchers with the Tampa Bay Rays at the deadline but were unable to get a deal done. Those talks were revisited this winter before Nick Fortes was ultimately dealt to Boston. 

That could leave Chicago looking at the free agent market to add another option to the backup catcher equation. If they do, Hedges, Higashioka and Vázquez are the three who fit the bill best.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy