The Myles Garrett trade has reignited questions about the Buffalo Bills' inability to land a superstar pass rusher during their Super Bowl window.
The Buffalo Bills have spent years searching for a dominant pass rusher capable of changing games in January.
As Myles Garrett heads to the Los Angeles Rams, it's fair to wonder whether Buffalo missed another opportunity to add exactly that type of player.
The debate surrounding Garrett's blockbuster move extends beyond a single trade. Instead, it highlights a growing frustration around the Bills' inability to land an elite edge rusher during one of the most successful stretches in franchise history.
Since Brandon Beane took over as general manager in 2017, Buffalo has built a perennial contender. The Bills have found their franchise quarterback in Josh Allen, won division titles, and consistently entered seasons with Super Bowl expectations'.
What they have not found is a true game-wrecking pass rusher.
Over the years, Buffalo has been linked to, or connected with, several star defenders. Trey Hendrickson, Maxx Crosby, Micah Parsons, and now Garrett have all generated speculation about whether the Bills could make a move. Yet each opportunity has ultimately passed without Buffalo landing the kind of defensive star capable of taking over a playoff game.
Garrett's move to Los Angeles only magnifies the discussion.
PODCAST | Can Brandon Beane Make The Big Move?
The Rams already had one of the NFL's brightest young defensive players in Jared Verse, yet they were willing to package significant assets, including Verse, to acquire a proven superstar. It's the type of aggressive move teams make when they believe a championship window is open right now.
For Buffalo, that same window has been open for years.
The challenge, of course, is that acquiring a player like Garrett is never simple. Cleveland reportedly wanted impact players in return, not just draft picks. Any deal involving the Bills likely would have started with Greg Rousseau and expanded from there. Trading a player of Garrett's caliber within the AFC also would have carried an additional premium.
Still, those realities do not eliminate the larger question.
At what point does the cost become worth it?
Elite pass rushers rarely become available. When they do, teams with championship aspirations must decide whether future assets are more valuable than a proven difference-maker. The Rams answered that question emphatically.
The Bills did not.
That doesn't mean Buffalo failed to pursue Garrett. It doesn't even mean a deal was realistically available. But as the Bills continue chasing their first Super Bowl championship, the conversation is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.
The roster remains talented enough to contend. Allen remains one of the league's best quarterbacks. The organization has consistently positioned itself among the NFL's elite.
Yet every postseason seems to reinforce the same reality: championship teams often have players capable of ending games on their own.
The Bills are still searching for theirs.
Bills Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk about all things Bills. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.
