As the Bills enter a critical offseason, wide receiver remains the biggest question. Sorting realistic options from wishful thinking reveals what Buffalo actually needs.
The Buffalo Bills aren’t in a spot where offseason wants can drift too far into fantasy.
This roster is still good. The window is still open. But it’s also clear that standing still isn’t an option, especially on offense. What Buffalo needs isn’t just more talent, it’s the right kind of talent, and that’s where these offseason conversations really start to matter.
Wide receiver is at the center of it for a reason.
The Bills don’t need five big new names. They need clarity. They need someone who can win on the outside, take pressure off the middle of the field, and make life easier for Josh Allen as games tighten. That’s why some names make sense, some don’t, and some sit squarely in the dream category.
Justin Jefferson was always the extreme example. Fun to talk about, almost impossible to execute, and not something worth building expectations around. If it happens, great, but nobody should be planning an offseason around lightning striking.
Once you move past that level of fantasy, the discussion gets more interesting.
Mike Evans is the cleanest fit on paper. He’s exactly what the Bills have lacked on the outside. Size, physicality, and a proven ability to win vertically. The age conversation is fair, but the role would be clear. He wouldn’t need to be everything. He’d need to be dependable. That matters more at this stage than upside.
Michael Pittman Jr. is the more nuanced option. He’s younger, he’s been productive in less-than-ideal quarterback situations, and there’s a strong argument that he hasn’t even hit his ceiling yet. Put him with a quarterback like Allen, and the numbers likely change. The appeal here is longevity. You’re not just renting production, you’re potentially locking in a core piece for several years.
Romeo Doubs sits in the middle of the realism spectrum. He’s productive, reliable, and does a lot of things well, but the fit question is real. Is he an outside answer or another piece that lives underneath? Buffalo already has players who can move chains. What they’re missing is someone defenses have to respect over the top. Doubs helps, but he might not solve the core issue.
Then there’s the more complicated conversation around someone like Dallas' George Pickens.
The talent is undeniable. The production is there. And if he were dropped into Buffalo’s offense tomorrow, he’d instantly become the most dangerous receiver on the roster. The concern isn’t whether he can play. It’s whether the Bills want to invite that kind of personality into a locker room that’s already trying to recalibrate.
At some point, though, production matters. Pickens, with his numbers, would have doubled Buffalo’s leading receiver output last season. That’s not nothing. The question becomes how much risk you’re willing to tolerate to fix a real problem. Then again, in the right situation, maybe there's no need to worry about personality at all.
On the other end of the spectrum are names that feel easier to dismiss. Jerry Jeudy fits that category. The inconsistency, the drops, and the lack of sustained production make him a hard sell as a trade candidate for a team that’s already lived through that experience.
There are quieter options too. Players like Christian Kirk, who has history with Allen, or Wan’Dale Robinson, who could add versatility, but neither fully answers the outside receiver question on their own.
That’s really what this all comes back to.
The Bills don’t need more bodies. They need a direction. Whether that means paying for stability, gambling on upside, or swinging big and dealing with the consequences, it has to be intentional.
Bills Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Bills. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.