Jim Harbaugh and Joe Hortiz face a pivotal choice as the Chargers search for a new offensive coordinator. Mike McDaniel brings innovation and explosiveness, while Brian Daboll offers balance and quarterback development.
Jim Harbaugh and Joe Hortiz have a massive decision ahead of them. After moving on from Greg Roman, the Chargers are tasked with finding an offensive coordinator who can finally unlock the full potential of Justin Herbert and bring consistency to an offense that fell short in the biggest moments. Among the most intriguing candidates are two former head coaches: Mike McDaniel and Brian Daboll.
With both set to interview in the coming days, it’s worth breaking down what each would bring to Los Angeles, and which might be the better fit.
Mike McDaniel: Innovation and Modern Offensive Design
Mike McDaniel is widely regarded as one of the brightest offensive minds in football. His background in the Shanahan coaching tree helped shape his reputation as a creative play-caller who emphasizes speed, spacing and pre-snap motion. During his time as head coach in Miami, McDaniel built one of the most explosive offenses in the league, maximizing elite talent while consistently staying a step ahead of defenses.
For the Chargers, McDaniel’s biggest appeal is how seamlessly his system could translate to Justin Herbert’s skill set. Herbert thrives when given freedom to push the ball downfield, and McDaniel’s offense is designed to create easy reads, mismatches and explosive plays. His ability to scheme receivers open would be a welcome change for a Chargers offense that often relied too heavily on individual talent rather than structure.
However, there are concerns. McDaniel’s offenses can be complex, requiring precise timing and elite speed at the skill positions. While the Chargers have building blocks, their roster does not currently mirror the Dolphins’ personnel. Additionally, McDaniel’s head coaching tenure raised questions about situational football and adaptability when defenses adjusted. As an offensive coordinator, though, those responsibilities would be reduced, allowing him to focus solely on what he does best—designing and calling plays.
Brian Daboll: Physicality and Quarterback Development
Brian Daboll brings a very different profile. Known for his work with Josh Allen in Buffalo, Daboll has built a reputation as a coach who can tailor an offense around his quarterback’s strengths. His systems have historically emphasized physicality, balance and adaptability rather than a single rigid scheme.
For the Chargers, Daboll’s biggest strength is his proven track record with a big-armed quarterback. Daboll helped transform Allen from a raw prospect into an MVP candidate, and that experience could translate well with Herbert. Daboll is comfortable adjusting game plans week-to-week and has shown the ability to succeed without perfect personnel, something that could appeal to Harbaugh’s more old-school football philosophy.
On the downside, Daboll’s offenses have not always been consistently elite. At times, his units have struggled with rhythm and efficiency, particularly when the run game stalled. There are also questions about whether his style is aggressive enough to fully maximize Herbert’s arm talent in today’s increasingly pass-heavy NFL.
Which Fits the Chargers Best?
Ultimately, this decision comes down to philosophy. Mike McDaniel offers innovation, explosiveness and a modern approach that could make the Chargers one of the league’s most exciting offenses. Brian Daboll offers stability, toughness and a quarterback-centric mindset that aligns well with Harbaugh’s emphasis on physical football.
If the Chargers want to fully lean into Herbert’s elite talent and modernize their offense, McDaniel may be the higher-upside choice. If they prioritize balance, adaptability and long-term consistency, Daboll could be the safer fit. Either way, Harbaugh and Hortiz cannot afford to miss—this hire may define the Chargers’ offensive identity for years to come.