Nov 7, 2026 6:14 PM
Updated Nov 12, 2026 1:45 PM
Carles Martinez’s midfield faces a structural identity crisis as defensive lapses and internal friction expose a tactical imbalance far deeper than a simple search for a specialist anchor.
Bayer Leverkusen's recent struggles have raised an important tactical question: does Carles Martínez's team genuinely lack a reliable defensive midfielder, or have the players become too dependent on their individual quality while neglecting the collective responsibilities required to compete at the highest level?
Robert Andrich's recent public criticism of Aleix García's reaction to his costly mistake against Marseille has only intensified the debate. Reports have also questioned Leverkusen's lack of a specialist holding midfielder capable of protecting the defence, breaking up opposition attacks, and providing stability during transitions. Yet with Andrich himself possessing many of those qualities, is the issue really a shortage of suitable players, or has Martínez simply failed to find the right balance in midfield?
Is A Defensive Midfielder Really The Solution?
Aleix García remains one of Die Werkself's most technically gifted midfielders. His passing range, vision, and ability to dictate the tempo are valuable assets, particularly against opponents who defend deep.
Related stories
However, dominating possession is not the same as controlling a football match.
Against Marseille, Leverkusen enjoyed 58% possession but struggled to turn that advantage into meaningful opportunities. More concerning was their vulnerability whenever possession changed hands.
A specialist holding midfielder could undoubtedly help address that weakness. García is naturally more comfortable influencing the game with the ball, while Andrich and Ezequiel Fernández offer different qualities in terms of defensive awareness, physicality, and positional discipline.
But would selecting a more defensive player automatically solve Leverkusen's problems?
The answer is unlikely to be that simple. Defensive stability depends on the positioning and coordination of the entire team. If midfielders advance too far, full-backs leave space behind them and attacking players fail to react quickly after losing possession, even the most disciplined defensive midfielder can find himself exposed.
The Werkself's difficulties, therefore, suggest a problem with the collective structure rather than simply the absence of one particular profile.
García's Mistake Exposed A Bigger Problem
The decisive moment against Marseille illustrated those concerns.
García failed to intercept a pass near the halfway line, allowing Amine Gouiri to exploit the space and launch the counterattack that resulted in the winning goal.
The initial mistake was understandable. What followed was considerably more troubling.
Rather than immediately attempting to recover his position, García appeared to dwell on his error, prompting public criticism from Andrich, who argued that losing possession can happen but failing to respond immediately should never be acceptable.
The comments were particularly striking given that Andrich, Leverkusen's former captain, is competing directly with García for a prominent role in midfield.
Such open criticism between teammates is unusual and suggests that frustrations over collective standards may be growing within the squad.
Nevertheless, García should not become the sole focus of Leverkusen's defensive problems.
The more important question is why the team's structure continues to offer so little protection when possession is lost.
When one unsuccessful interception can leave the defence facing such a dangerous situation, the problem extends beyond the individual responsible for the mistake. Die Werkself must examine how they position themselves behind the ball and whether enough players are prepared to react when an attack breaks down.
Have Leverkusen Become Too Reliant On Their Quality?
Perhaps the more revealing explanation lies in Leverkusen's overall approach.
Martínez has a squad capable of dominating possession and deciding matches through individual brilliance. Ibrahim Maza can create opportunities in tight spaces, García can dictate the rhythm of possession, and Patrik Schick remains a significant threat inside the penalty area.
Yet technical superiority alone is not enough to guarantee results.
There is a difference between playing with confidence and becoming overly reliant on the belief that individual quality will eventually make the difference.
Bayer have frequently enjoyed lengthy spells of possession without consistently imposing themselves on opponents. When those periods fail to produce goals, their defensive vulnerabilities become even more costly.
That does not necessarily mean the players lack commitment. Injuries, fatigue and a demanding schedule have undoubtedly complicated Martínez's task.
However, successful teams cannot afford to treat defensive responsibility as something separate from their attacking ambitions.
The strongest sides combine technical quality with collective discipline. Their players instinctively recognise when to counterpress, when to retreat and when to prevent an opponent from exploiting an open transition.
The Bundesliga side have not demonstrated that understanding consistently enough.
The concern is that the team sometimes appears more focused on what it can achieve with possession than on how it should react without it.
Martínez Must Fix The System, Not Just The Selection
Martínez has already acknowledged that his team's problems extend beyond individual performances.
"We need to clear our heads. We need to improve mentally, especially when it comes to sticking together and working as a team, to be competitive. We need to break this run of poor results."
His assessment points towards an issue that cannot be resolved through tactical changes alone.
Greater defensive responsibility for Andrich or Fernández could provide García with more freedom to influence possession while ensuring the backline receives adequate protection.
However, Martínez must also establish clearer responsibilities for his full-backs, improve the team's positioning during attacking phases and demand a more coordinated response whenever possession is lost.
Simply replacing one midfielder without correcting those structural weaknesses would risk reproducing the same problems with different personnel.
Sunday's derby against Köln represents an important opportunity to demonstrate progress, particularly after three defeats in Leverkusen's last four competitive matches.
The debate surrounding the absence of a natural holding midfielder is justified, but it should not distract from the broader tactical picture.
Perhaps Leverkusen's biggest problem is not that they lack a player capable of providing defensive stability, but that they have become too reliant on their individual strengths without maintaining the collective discipline needed to support them.
A proper No. 6 might improve the balance of the team, but no single midfielder can compensate for an entire side failing to fulfil its defensive responsibilities.
1
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy



