Winners and Losers From White Sox Trade With Rockies
Nov 20, 2026 7:27 PM

The Chicago White Sox shook up their starting rotation by trading Davis Martin and Luis Castillo to the Colorado Rockies, a move with significant implications for several players.

On Thursday night, the Chicago White Sox made a deal with the Colorado Rockies, sending right-handed pitchers Davis Martin and Luis Castillo to Colorado in exchange for two prospects.

Left-handed pitcher Sean Sullivan and catcher Douglas Veliz are the two players coming back to Chicago in the trade. This deal, though, was more about salary relief than anything for the White Sox.

Getting Castillo's contract off the books and saving over $20 million opens up a number of possibilities for what could still happen in free agency.

We know the White Sox are still looking for at least one starting pitcher and a right-handed hitting outfielder. The market is going to move quickly between now and December 1, with contracts being agreed to on a daily basis. The White Sox have now positioned themselves to swim in the deep waters should they choose to do so.

Related stories

Looking back at the trade, let's break down who the real winners and losers are of an unexpected salary dump deal.

Winner - Noah Schultz

Noah Schultz is a winner here. The 23-year-old left-hander will be competing for a rotation spot in spring training, but three places in the starting rotation are already occupied by Sean Burke, Dustin May, and Grant Taylor.

Having both Castillo and Martin on the roster only added more competition. Martin is more proven than Schultz is, and Castillo was getting paid a lot of money that may have left the White Sox feeling obligated to give him runway.

Even now, with another free agent signing likely on the way, the door is wide open for Noah Schultz to earn the final spot in the White Sox starting rotation. His odds of making the Opening Day roster just went up. That's a win for Schultz.

Loser - Davis Martin

What else can really be said here? Davis Martin had been with the White Sox since his MLB debut in May of 2022. He was on the team when they finished 41-121 in 2024, yet always expressed a desire to be part of the organization's turnaround. He nearly made the AL All-Star team representing the White Sox in 2026 but had a really rough second half while battling injuries that ultimately led to the White Sox not trusting him to start a playoff game.

Martin wanted to be in Chicago, and his White Sox teammates wanted him here. And now, not only has he been traded, but he goes to a pitcher's worst nightmare in Colorado.

For a pitcher who was in the fourth percentile in hard-hit rate last season, I'm not sure Martin is going to have the same success with the Rockies that he did in a White Sox uniform. Not to mention the fact that he went from a team with aspirations of contending in the American League to a team that will just be trying not to lose 100 games in 2027.

Winner - Free Agent Pitchers

Freddy Peralta, Michael King, and Trevor Rogers are all winners here. It remains to be seen what the White Sox might offer their next starting pitching target, but according to MLB insider Jim Bowden, Chicago is one of the teams still pursuing Peralta as the shutdown closes in.

With the salary relief gained from this trade, the White Sox could now be players for that top tier of free agent starting pitchers. Adding another team to the bidding war will only drive the market price up.

Loser - The Monfort Family

Perhaps Davis Martin pitches well and makes this a worthwhile investment for Rockies owners Dick and Charlie Monfort, but having watched Luis Castillo in 2026, it's hard to imagine how ugly things could get now that he's pitching at Coors Field.

The Rockies might be taking on this contract in preparation for a potential salary floor being implemented. But anytime a team is uncompetitive and an owner is paying over $20 million to a player who's potentially detrimental to the cause, it's a hard pill to swallow.

The only player set to make more money from the Colorado Rockies in 2027 than Luis Castillo is Kris Bryant. I wouldn't be surprised if neither one of those guys was actually on the active roster come July. Why not just spend that money in free agency to acquire players who can actually impact winning?

Winner - Sean Sullivan

Early in his professional career, left-handed pitcher Sean Sullivan made 25 starts at the Double-A level, going 11-6 with a 2.85 ERA over 129.1 innings. He had a great 2025 season, was only 22 years old, and was considered a top-10 prospect in the Rockies' farm system.

2026 wasn't as strong. Sullivan posted a 5.31 ERA over 14 starts with Triple-A Albuquerque and then a really rough 8.87 ERA in five MLB appearances for the Rockies. Both Albuquerque and Colorado are difficult places to pitch, especially when you don't overwhelm hitters with stuff or miss bats consistently.

Sullivan's stock took a big hit last year, particularly in the eyes of the Rockies, who probably started to feel like he wasn't a match for Coors Field. With this trade, Sullivan gets a fresh start in the White Sox organization, where he'll have an opportunity to further his development under a new coaching staff.

White Sox GM Chris Getz has already expressed some optimism about Sullivan as a potential project to tinker with and another young left-hander who adds depth to Chicago's pitching pool.

Who knows what's in store for him in Chicago, but from the outside looking in, it seemed like Sullivan needed a fresh start. And the White Sox gave him one.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy